Court mandates police oversight for similar cases, emphasizing the protection of minors' rights and freedom
In a recent judgment passed by the Allahabad High Court, Justice Praveen Kumar Giri criticized the inefficiency of police investigations in the case concerning the recovery of a minor girl, Savitri, aged about 12 years. The court intervened after a lackluster investigation by the police led to the minor's prolonged disappearance. The case had been brought to the court's attention through a Habeas Corpus petition filed by Savitri's father, Bhagani, who had been searching for his daughter for the past four months.
The judgment, dated June 8, 2026, highlighted the severe lapses in police procedures, noting that the minor was only recovered after the court's intervention. The court has handed over the custody of Savitri to her father, with a directive that he must ensure her presence before the court or police whenever required. This decision was made in the presence of the bar and Deputy Commissioner of Police, Lucknow, Deeksha Sharma.
Justice Giri expressed grave concern over the negligent investigation conducted by Sub Inspector Ashwani Kumar Rai, who failed to make adequate efforts to search for the missing minor. The court's intervention underscored the need for competent officers who can handle such sensitive matters with the seriousness they deserve, particularly when they pertain to the life and liberty of minors.
Furthermore, the Deputy Commissioner of Police was instructed to oversee similar cases within her jurisdiction and report back to the court within three days. The court emphasized the need for vigilance among police officers, urging the deployment of competent personnel to prevent further incidents of missing minors. Additionally, the Deputy Commissioner is tasked with identifying unreported cases of missing minors and submitting a comprehensive report at the next hearing.
The judgment also extended directives to the Commissioner of Police, Lucknow, requiring an explanation regarding similar incidents across all police stations in the city. The court has scheduled the next hearing for June 10, 2026, where further assessments and updates are expected.
This ruling reflects the court's commitment to safeguarding the rights and freedoms of minors, ensuring that law enforcement agencies are held accountable for their responsibilities. The judgment serves as a stern reminder of the importance of diligent and efficient police work in protecting vulnerable individuals.
Bottom Line:
Habeas Corpus - Recovery of minor girl - Custody handed over to father - Investigation by police found lacking - Directions issued for proper monitoring and investigation in similar cases.
Statutory provision(s): Habeas Corpus, Investigation Procedures, Administrative Directions
Savitri v. State of U.P., (Allahabad)(Lucknow) : Law Finder Doc id # 2921089
