Court says coconut is not a fruit for market-yard purposes; licence for fruits and vegetables does not permit trading in green coconut at Sahibabad mandi
The Allahabad High Court has dismissed a writ petition filed by M/s Three Star Fruit Company challenging the restriction on trading in coconut at Navin Phal Sabzi Mandi Sthal, Sahibabad, Ghaziabad. A division bench of Justice Alok Mathur and Justice Amitabh Kumar Rai held that coconut, as classified under the U.P. Krishi Utpadan Mandi Adhiniyam, 1964, falls under the category of “A-Agriculture” and “III-Oilseeds,” and therefore cannot be traded in a fruit and vegetable market yard.
The petitioner had sought a mandamus directing the authorities to allow entry and trade of fresh or green coconut in the mandi yard. It also challenged the 30 January 1995 notification, under which coconut was included in the Schedule as an oilseed, arguing that coconut is botanically a fruit and should instead be placed under “Fruits” in the horticulture category.
The Court rejected this argument, noting that the statutory scheme of the Mandi Adhiniyam distinguishes between the Schedule under Section 4-A and the separate notifications under Sections 6 and 8, which determine whether a commodity is a “specified agricultural produce” for a particular market area. The bench observed that coconut was once included in the list of specified agricultural produce in 1996, but was later excluded by a 2003 notification. As a result, coconut ceased to be a commodity that could be traded in the Sahibabad market area under the earlier market-fee regime.
The Court further held that the later user charge regime introduced in 2020 and the government order of 17 September 2021 did not help the petitioner. Even though coconut was included for user-charge purposes, it was categorised under oilseeds, not fruits and vegetables. Since Navin Phal Sabzi Mandi Sthal is a specialised fruit and vegetable market yard, trade in coconut cannot be permitted there, the bench said.
On the challenge to the classification itself, the Court relied on several Supreme Court decisions and held that coconut is commercially understood in multiple forms, including green coconut, watery coconut, dried coconut and copra. It noted that coconut is commonly associated with oil extraction and industrial use, and its placement under oilseeds is neither arbitrary nor illegal. The Court also rejected the contention that green coconut alone should be treated as a fruit for the purpose of trading in the mandi.
The bench additionally held that the petitioner’s licence for fruit and vegetable trade did not confer any legal right to trade in coconut. Mere past inaction by the authorities in allowing such trade could not create a vested right, the Court said.
Accordingly, the High Court upheld the State’s action and dismissed the writ petition, bringing an end to the challenge against the restriction on coconut trade in the Sahibabad fruit and vegetable mandi.
Bottom Line:
Trade in coconut, categorized under "A-Agriculture" and "III-Oilseeds" in the U.P. Krishi Utpadan Mandi Adhiniyam, 1964, cannot be permitted in a Fruit and Vegetable Market Yard. Classification of coconut under the "Oilseeds" category is consistent with its commercial and industrial use for oil extraction and is not arbitrary.
Statutory provision(s): Section 2(a), Section 2(k), Section 2(o), Section 2(s-2), Section 2(t), Section 2(w), Section 4-A, Section 5, Section 6, Section 7, Section 7-C, Section 8, Section 9, Section 17(iii)(b), Section 17(iii)(c) of the U.P. Krishi Utpadan Mandi Adhiniyam, 1964, Article 14, Article 19(1)(g), Article 226 of the Constitution of India
M/s Three Star Fruit Company v. State of U.P., (All)(DB)(Lucknow) : Law Finder Doc id # 3102164