LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Bombay High Court Restores Bail of Accused in Social Activist Murder Case, Citing Lack of Cogent Evidence for Bail Cancellation

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Bombay High Court Restores Bail of Accused in Social Activist Murder Case, Citing Lack of Cogent Evidence for Bail Cancellation

Court emphasizes need for concrete proof over political rivalry claims in witness intimidation allegations; imposes stringent conditions for bail continuation


In a significant ruling delivered on November 2, 2026, the Bombay High Court quashed the Sessions Court's order that had canceled the bail of Chandrabhan @ Bhanu Vishwanath Khalde, the accused in the high-profile murder case of a social activist. The Court restored the bail granted to the 65-year-old applicant, underscoring that bail cancellation cannot be ordered merely on unsubstantiated allegations, especially in a politically charged case.


The accused, implicated primarily on circumstantial evidence and charges of conspiracy, was initially granted bail by the Sessions Court in April 2024. Despite facing serious accusations, including alleged attempts to threaten prosecution witnesses, the High Court held that the mere presence of political rivalry and uncorroborated claims do not justify revoking bail.


The case revolves around the murder of a social activist on May 12, 2023, which allegedly involved multiple accused persons. The First Informant, mother of the deceased and affiliated with the victim's political party, lodged the FIR, initially naming seven accused but not including Chandrabhan. His implication surfaced during the investigation based on suspicion and circumstantial links, such as CCTV footage showing visits to his residence by other accused.


The Sessions Court canceled Chandrabhan's bail on October 1, 2026, citing violations of bail conditions, including witness intimidation. However, the High Court noted that the Sessions Court failed to consider earlier well-reasoned orders by this Court and the Supreme Court, which had dismissed prior attempts to revoke bail. The High Court observed that the allegations of witness tampering stemmed mainly from politically affiliated witnesses, raising concerns about their impartiality.


Notably, the High Court drew attention to the affidavit of an independent witness who denied any threats, and the conflicting affidavits suggesting possible financial pressure among witnesses, further casting doubt on the prosecution's claims. The Court emphasized that cancellation of bail demands cogent material demonstrating deliberate misuse of liberty or interference with justice, which was absent in this case.


Considering the applicant's age, permanent residence, and cooperation with the investigation, the Court concluded that the Sessions Court's order was unsustainable. It reinstated the bail with stringent conditions to safeguard the trial's integrity, including prohibiting the accused from entering the Sessions Court's jurisdiction except for hearings, maintaining regular court appearances, refraining from influencing witnesses, and keeping the investigating officer informed of contact details.


The Court clarified that its observations were limited to the bail proceedings and did not comment on the merits of the case, leaving the trial to proceed on evidence alone.


This judgment reaffirms the principle that bail, once granted, should not be canceled lightly or on the basis of political vendetta or vague allegations, protecting the fundamental right to liberty unless clear and convincing material justifies otherwise.


Bottom Line:

Cancellation of bail cannot be ordered merely based on unsubstantiated allegations or political rivalry; there must be cogent evidence demonstrating deliberate misuse of liberty by the accused.


Statutory provision(s):

Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 - Section 439(2)


Chandrabhan @ Bhanu Vishwanath Khalde v. State of Maharashtra, (Bombay) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3017439

Share this article: