Court says Assessing Officer had no jurisdiction to ignore binding directions of the Dispute Resolution Panel; Revenue’s appeal dismissed.
The Delhi High Court has dismissed the Income Tax Department’s appeals against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) that had quashed assessment orders passed against Bechtel Limited for Assessment Years 2016-17 and 2017-18.
A Division Bench of Justice Subramonium Prasad and Justice Renu Bhatnagar held that the Assessing Officer failed to implement the binding directions issued by the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP) under Section 144C of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The Court said this failure rendered the final assessment orders “without jurisdiction” and “void ab initio.”
The dispute arose from engineering and procurement support services provided by the UK-based company to Reliance Industries Limited in connection with a project at Jamnagar. The Assessing Officer had treated the receipts as Fees for Technical Services (FTS)/Fee for Included Services (FIS). Bechtel objected before the DRP, which found that the company had a business connection and Permanent Establishment (PE) in India and directed that the receipts be taxed as business income under Articles 6 and 7 of the India-UK DTAA. The DRP also observed that the services were technical in nature, but held that the income would nevertheless be taxable as business income because of the PE.
However, while passing the final assessment orders, the Assessing Officer did not fully follow the DRP’s directions and continued to treat the receipts substantively as FTS. The ITAT held that this amounted to non-compliance with the mandatory scheme of Section 144C and quashed the assessment orders.
Before the High Court, the Revenue argued that the DRP had issued twin directions and that the ITAT should have examined the merits of the taxability or remanded the matter. The Court rejected this submission, noting that the issue was squarely covered by its earlier decision in ESPN Star Sports Mauritius S.N.C. v. Union of India. In that case too, the Court had held that the Assessing Officer must strictly comply with the DRP’s directions and cannot substitute his own view.
The Bench observed that the Revenue’s reliance on Anand NVH Products was misplaced because the facts were different. In the present case, unlike that matter, the Assessing Officer had not acted in accordance with the DRP’s binding directions.
Finding no error in the ITAT’s reasoning, the High Court refused to admit the appeals and dismissed them. Pending applications were also dismissed.
Bottom Line:
Income Tax - Assessment order quashed by ITAT for non-implementation of DRP's binding directions under Section 144C(10) read with Section 144C(13) of the Income Tax Act, rendering the assessment order without jurisdiction and void ab initio.
Statutory provision(s): Section 144C(10), Section 144C(13), Section 260A, Section 143(1), Section 143(2), Section 143(3), Section 147, Section 44DA, Section 9(1)(vii) of the Income Tax Act, 1961
Commissioner of Income Tax v. Bechtel Limited, (Delhi)(DB) : Law Finder Doc id # 3018747