LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Felling of trees: SC asks trader to pay Rs 50 lakh to welfare institutions for purging contempt

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Felling of trees: SC asks trader to pay Rs 50 lakh to welfare institutions for purging contempt

New Delhi, Nov 19 The Supreme Court on Thursday asked a businessman, facing contempt proceedings for illegally felling 454 trees on his private land at Mathura-Vrindavan, to deposit Rs 50 lakh as donations to five Uttar Pradesh government-run or aided institutions working for the welfare of widows, destitutes and ailing persons to close the contempt case.


A bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana took note of the submissions of senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for Shanker Agarwal alias Shiv Shankar Agarwal, that his client has already suffered a lot.


The senior lawyer said that a penalty of Rs 4.54 crore, one lakh per tree, was imposed on him for illegally felling trees on his own land.


Besides, he purchased 9.46 hectares of land after paying Rs 2 crore and transferred that to the state government for compensatory afforestation, Rohatgi said, adding that around 50 lakh was also paid for plantation and care of saplings.


Moreover, Agarwal remained in jail for almost a month, he said, and urged the bench to purge the contempt.


Taking note of the submissions, the bench directed that the land provided by Agarwal to the state government be declared as forest within eight weeks.


The CJI asked the court-appointed Central Empowered Committee to inspect the site and file a compliance report on compensatory afforestation to be undertaken on the land transferred to the state's forest department.


The bench directed that the Rs 4.54 crore amount deposited earlier by Agarwal be used for afforestation in Mathura-Vrindavan area and, if the money is already spent for this purpose, then a compliance report be filed.


The bench then ordered taking back its earlier coercive orders and purging the contempt against Agarwal if he deposited Rs 10 lakh each to five Uttar Pradesh government-run or aided institutions, working for the welfare of widows, destitutes and ailing persons, at Mathura-Vrindavan in four weeks.


In March 2025, a bench led by Justice A S Oka, since retired, had imposed a Rs 4.54-crore fine on Agarwal for illegally felling 454 trees in Mathura-Vrindavan.


The court had refused to show leniency and ordered him to pay Rs 1 lakh per tree, stating that cutting down a large number of trees is worse than killing a human being.


In September 2024, Agarwal used JCB machines overnight to clear 454 trees at Dalmia Farms in Vrindavan to develop a real estate colony. Of those trees, 32 stood on a roadside strip of protected forest land.


Dalmia Farms, which was purchased by Agarwal, falls inside the ecologically sensitive Taj Trapezium Zone (TTZ), which is strictly monitored under long-standing Supreme Court environmental mandates.


Following a report from the CEC, Justice Oka-led bench had issued a contempt notice to Agarwal in December, 2024.

Share this article: