Court says adultery and cruelty must be proved with cogent evidence; mere suspicion, vague allegations and uncorroborated claims cannot justify divorce.
The Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court has dismissed a husband’s civil miscellaneous appeals and upheld a Family Court order refusing divorce while granting restitution of conjugal rights to the wife in a matrimonial dispute.
A Division Bench of Justice G.R. Swaminathan and Justice M.D. Sumathi confirmed the Family Court’s common judgment dated 6 December 2021 in two connected matrimonial original petitions arising out of the marriage solemnised on 23 August 2018 at Kaalapur village.
The husband had sought dissolution of marriage under Sections 13(1)(i) and 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, alleging that his wife was living in adultery, had concealed material facts about her age and family background, refused to perform household duties, did not consummate the marriage, and subjected him to mental cruelty. The wife denied all allegations and, in turn, sought restitution of conjugal rights under Section 9 of the Act.
The Family Court had dismissed the husband’s divorce petition and allowed the wife’s petition for restitution. Challenging that decision, the husband argued before the High Court that the Family Court had ignored evidence showing his wife’s alleged illicit relationship with a person named Viji and had failed to appreciate the cruelty caused to him by her conduct.
However, the High Court found no reason to interfere with the Family Court’s conclusions. The Bench reiterated that allegations of adultery are serious and must be proved by cogent and convincing evidence. It held that the husband had not established that he personally witnessed any adulterous act, and that the mere presence of Viji in the matrimonial house was insufficient to infer adultery. The Court also noted that no family members who were allegedly present at the time were examined, and the evidence of the husband’s witness was found inadequate.
On the issue of cruelty, the Court observed that mental cruelty must be assessed on the basis of the nature, seriousness and cumulative effect of the conduct complained of. It held that vague allegations regarding cooking, serving food, telephone conversations and refusal to consummate the marriage were not supported by sufficient evidence to meet the legal threshold for cruelty.
The Bench further upheld the wife’s claim for restitution of conjugal rights, noting that she had consistently expressed her willingness to resume matrimonial life and that the husband had failed to establish any legally sufficient ground to deny that relief.
Concluding that the appeal merely sought a different appreciation of the same evidence, the High Court dismissed both appeals and confirmed the Family Court’s order in full. There was no order as to costs.
Bottom Line:
Matrimonial disputes - Allegations of adultery and cruelty must be established by cogent evidence and meet the standard of preponderance of probabilities. Mere suspicion or unsubstantiated allegations do not suffice for dissolution of marriage.
Statutory provision(s): Sections 13(1)(i), 13(1)(ia), and 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955
M.Subramanian v. V.Kalaiarasi, (Madras)(DB)(Madurai Bench) : Law Finder Doc id # 3012533