LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Madras High Court Upholds Plaintiff's Copyright Ownership but Dismisses Rs.26 Lakh Damages Claim in Musical Work Infringement Case

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Madras High Court Upholds Plaintiff's Copyright Ownership but Dismisses Rs.26 Lakh Damages Claim in Musical Work Infringement Case

Court finds plaintiff's copyright ownership established; however, lack of evidence on monetary loss leads to dismissal of damages claim against MPF Studios and co-defendant


In a significant copyright infringement dispute concerning the use of a musical composition in an advertisement, the Madras High Court delivered its judgment on November 4, 2026, in the case of Arun Suradhan v. MPF Studios and Another (C.S. No. 2 of 2017). The plaintiff, Arun Suradhan, a noted music composer, had claimed ownership of copyright over a musical work created for an advertisement produced by the first defendant, MPF Studios, on behalf of the second defendant, a corporate IT and ITES company.


The plaintiff initiated the suit seeking damages of Rs.26,00,000 for alleged infringement of his copyright and breach of two Commercial Music Contract Agreements (CMCA) dated November 3, 2014, and February 23, 2015. These agreements stipulated the terms of use and the period for which the defendants could utilize the musical work, which was limited to November 3, 2015.


The court found that the plaintiff's ownership of the musical work's copyright was unequivocally established. This was affirmed by the admission of the first defendant's authorized signatory during cross-examination. It was also acknowledged that the second defendant was made aware of the terms of the CMCA through the first defendant. Despite these admissions, the court noted that the plaintiff failed to provide sufficient and cogent evidence to substantiate the quantum of damages claimed.


The plaintiff contended that the defendants continued to use the musical work beyond the agreed expiry date, including on AIR radio channels and online platforms such as YouTube. The plaintiff also asserted that this unauthorized use caused substantial financial loss and damage to his reputation. However, the court highlighted several inconsistencies and deficiencies in the evidence presented to support these claims.


Notably, the plaintiff's primary evidence for the claimed losses was an offer letter from M/s. Dazu Entertainment, indicating potential commercial opportunities lost due to the infringement. The court pointed out that this evidence was introduced late, three years after filing the suit, and was not pleaded in the original plaint, thereby weakening its credibility. The witness from M/s. Dazu Entertainment also failed to establish concrete links between the alleged losses and the infringement.


The court further observed that the plaintiff had engaged in negotiations with the defendants for renewal of the agreements post-expiry, which indicated a degree of acquiescence. However, this did not amount to condonation of infringement as the plaintiff had continuously called upon the defendants to cease unauthorized use.


The second defendant had settled with the plaintiff through a mediated agreement during the pendency of the suit, which included a payment of Rs.2,50,000 without admitting the allegations. As a result, the suit against the second defendant was partly decreed as per the settlement terms.


Ultimately, the court dismissed the plaintiff's suit for damages against the first defendant, MPF Studios, concluding that while copyright infringement and breach of contract were established, the claim for Rs.26,00,000 damages was unsubstantiated. The judgment underscored the importance of detailed and timely evidence in claims for monetary compensation in intellectual property disputes.


Bottom Line:

Copyright - Infringement of musical work - Plaintiff claimed ownership of copyright and alleged breach of agreements by defendants - Court held that plaintiff's copyright ownership was established, but claim for damages was not substantiated due to lack of evidence.


Statutory provision(s):

Copyright Act, 1957 - Section 55


Arun Suradhan v. MPF Studios, (Madras) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3025562

Share this article: