LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Maharashtra Consumer Commission Orders Bombay Realty to Refund Rs 1.95 Crore to Flat Buyers with Interest

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Maharashtra Consumer Commission Orders Bombay Realty to Refund Rs 1.95 Crore to Flat Buyers with Interest

Arbitration clause cannot block consumer complaint, says State Commission; buyers also awarded compensation for mental agony and litigation costs


The Maharashtra State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Mumbai, has directed Bombay Realty and The Bombay Dyeing & Manufacturing Co. Ltd. to refund Rs 1,95,94,431 to two homebuyers, along with 9% annual interest from the dates of deposit, holding the developer guilty of deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.


The order was passed in Consumer Complaint No. CC/188/2022 by a bench comprising Presiding Member Ms. Poonam V. Maharshi and Member Dr. Nisha Amol Chavhan on 3 November 2026.


The complaint was filed by Raj Kumar Agarwal and Rahul Agarwal, who had booked Flat No. 801 measuring 1,941 sq. ft. with two car parking spaces in the “Two ICC” project at Island City Centre, Dadar (East), Mumbai. The total consideration for the apartment was Rs 9.94 crore. The buyers paid an initial booking amount of Rs 25 lakh in August 2014 and, according to the record, deposited a total of Rs 1.95 crore, including TDS.


The buyers told the Commission that they had booked the apartment based on the developer’s assurances of timely completion. However, construction was delayed by more than a year. They said that although discussions were held to revise the original 30:70 payment plan to a construction-linked payment schedule, the developer instead continued to raise demands under the old scheme and later issued a pre-termination letter in September 2016 threatening cancellation and forfeiture.


The complainants cancelled the booking in October 2016 and sought a full refund with interest. The developer, however, did not return the money and continued issuing demands. The dispute also saw criminal proceedings in Jamshedpur, which eventually ended after the Jharkhand High Court quashed the FIR in December 2021 and the Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition in May 2022, while leaving civil remedies open. The buyers then approached the consumer commission in August 2022.


Bombay Realty opposed the complaint mainly on two grounds. First, it argued that the case was barred by limitation because the cause of action arose in 2016. Second, it claimed that the booking application contained an arbitration clause, which meant the dispute should not be heard by the consumer commission. The developer also contended that the dispute arose from payment defaults by the buyers and that it was entitled to cancel the allotment and forfeit part of the amount under the contract.


Rejecting these objections, the Commission held that the complaint was within limitation. It observed that the refund dispute, related litigation, and attempts at resolution continued up to the Supreme Court’s order dated 13 May 2022. The Commission also noted that the developer had issued a fresh demand letter on 3 January 2022, showing that the transaction was still being treated as subsisting. On that basis, it ruled that the case involved a continuous cause of action and a continuing wrong, making the complaint timely under Section 69 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.


On the arbitration issue, the Commission held that an arbitration clause does not oust the jurisdiction of consumer fora. Referring to Sections 3 and 100 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, and the Supreme Court ruling in Aftab Singh v. Emaar MGF Land Ltd., it said remedies under the consumer law are in addition to those available under other laws.


On merits, the Commission found that the buyers had undeniably paid Rs 1.95 crore and that the project had suffered delays. It held that when a developer fails to hand over possession within a reasonable time while retaining substantial amounts paid by homebuyers, such conduct amounts to deficiency in service and unfair trade practice. The Commission further said that standard-form forfeiture clauses in builder agreements cannot override the equitable jurisdiction of consumer courts.


Relying on Supreme Court decisions in Pioneer Urban Land & Infrastructure Ltd. v. Govindan Raghavan and Experion Developers (P) Ltd. v. Sushma Ashok Shiroor, the Commission reiterated that a flat purchaser cannot be made to wait indefinitely for possession and is entitled to a refund with reasonable interest if the builder defaults.


Allowing the complaint, the Commission directed the opposite parties, jointly and severally, to refund the full principal amount of Rs 1,95,94,431 with interest at 9% per annum from the respective dates of deposit until realization. It also awarded Rs 1 lakh as compensation for mental agony, harassment and deficiency in service, and Rs 50,000 towards litigation costs.


The ruling reinforces the position that homebuyers can seek consumer remedies against delayed real estate projects despite arbitration clauses in builder-buyer agreements.


Bottom Line:

A consumer complaint alleging deficiency in service and unfair trade practices by a real estate developer is maintainable despite an arbitration clause in the agreement, and the complainant is entitled to a refund of the deposited amount with interest and compensation for mental agony.


Statutory provision(s): Consumer Protection Act, 2019, Section 47, Section 69, Section 3, Section 100, Section 2(11), Section 2(47)


Raj Kumar Agarwal v. Bombay Realty, (MAHSCDRC)(Mumbai) : Law Finder Doc id # 3026489

Share this article: