Court Recognizes Matrilineal Traditions, Permits Quashing of Proceedings Where Consent is Informed and Parties Cohabiting with Child; Directs Government to Ensure Welfare Benefits for Victim and Child
In a landmark judgment dated October 28, 2026, the Meghalaya High Court, led by Chief Justice Mrs. Revati Mohite Dere, quashed an FIR registered under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO), 2012, involving two adults who began their consensual relationship as adolescents. The petitioners, Dakhutmeki Shylla and another, had challenged the FIR and subsequent trial proceedings, asserting that their relationship was consensual, they are presently cohabiting as husband and wife, and have a six-year-old child.
The court carefully considered the unique socio-cultural context of Meghalaya, a state known for its matrilineal societal structure among the Khasi, Garo, and Jaintia tribes. This system, which grants women significant social and economic independence-including the freedom to choose partners and custody of ancestral property-was a pivotal factor in the court's decision. The court acknowledged that many adolescent consensual relationships in Meghalaya culminate in live-in arrangements or marriages, often resulting in children, and that such relationships are socially accepted.
To ensure that justice is served fairly, the court relied on detailed reports from the High Court Legal Services Committee and the local police station. These reports confirmed that the female petitioner had voluntarily and knowingly consented to the relationship, that she and the petitioner were living together with their child, and that the petitioner was financially supporting the family. Importantly, the female petitioner expressed no objection to quashing the proceedings.
The court reiterated its earlier observations from the case of Shri Shalenbor Wahlang v. State of Meghalaya (2026), emphasizing that quashing POCSO proceedings is permissible in exceptional cases involving consensual adolescent relationships, provided the consent is informed, voluntary, and free from coercion. The judgment stressed that the court's discretion in such matters must be exercised with great caution, balancing the need for deterrence with rehabilitation and social realities.
In a significant directive, the court ordered the Deputy Commissioner of the District Child Protection Office and the Secretary of the District Legal Services Authority to ensure that the petitioner and her child receive all applicable benefits under various State and Central Government welfare schemes. These include the Nirbhaya Fund, Mission Vatsalya Scheme, Beti Bachao Beti Padhao, Meghalaya Victim Compensation Scheme, Ayushman Bharat, and others aimed at supporting victims of sexual offences and their children. Furthermore, the court mandated the appointment of a support person to assist the petitioner in continuing her education, recognizing the financial constraints that had previously interrupted her studies.
The court underscored that while POCSO cases address offences against society at large, enforcement of the law must be tempered with empathy and fairness, particularly where the victim and accused have built a family and are living as partners. Sending the accused to jail in such cases, the court observed, would result in greater injustice to both the victim and the child.
The judgment also called upon the State Government to increase awareness about the POCSO Act, especially in rural and remote areas, to educate adolescents and communities about legal provisions and penalties.
The FIR registered at Khliehriat Women Police Station, East Jaintia Hills District, and the ongoing trial before the Special Judge POCSO, Khliehriat, were consequently quashed and set aside.
This decision marks a progressive judicial approach that respects local customs and prioritizes the welfare of victims and their children, while maintaining the integrity of the law.
Bottom Line:
Quashing of FIR under POCSO Act permissible in cases of consensual adolescent relationships, where the consent given by the victim is informed, and parties are cohabiting or married with a child. Consideration must be given to the socio-cultural context and ensuring the victim and child's welfare through relevant government schemes.
Statutory provision(s):
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012, Sections 4, 6, 528 - Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, Section 528.
Dakhutmeki Shylla v. State of Meghalaya, (Meghalaya) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3019137