Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process Terminated; Corporate Debtor Restored to Pre-CIRP Status Amid Findings of Concealment and Unauthorized Board Actions
In a significant judgment dated October 30, 2026, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), Principal Bench, New Delhi, dismissed appeals filed by Intarvo Technologies Private Limited and Sonoma Management Partners Private Limited, upholding the adjudicating authority's decision to recall the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) initiated against Intarvo. The bench, comprising Justice Mohammad Faiz Alam Khan and Arun Baroka, found that the insolvency proceedings had been initiated fraudulently and maliciously, warranting termination of the CIRP and restoration of the corporate debtor to its original status before the insolvency process began.
The controversy arose when Intarvo Technologies filed an application under Section 10 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016, acknowledging default in payment of over ₹2.29 crores, comprising operational and financial debts. Notably, a decree for ₹47.09 lakhs had been passed against Intarvo in favor of Vivek Jairath, a creditor who was deliberately omitted from the list of operational creditors in the insolvency application. Vivek Jairath subsequently filed an application under Section 65 of the IBC alleging fraudulent initiation of CIRP with the intent to exclude his claim.
The adjudicating authority found multiple irregularities, including:
- Concealment of the subsisting decree passed in favor of Vivek Jairath dated November 5, 2022, which was a material liability that Intarvo failed to disclose in the Section 10 application.
- Invalid authorization for filing the Section 10 application, as the board of directors, appointed as additional directors in March 2019, had their terms expire in September 2019, rendering the extraordinary general meeting held in December 2022 and the special resolution passed therein unauthorized.
- The write-off of a substantial ₹7.05 crore in receivables from related parties in the audited balance sheet of FY 2019-20, without adequate disclosure or recovery measures.
- Inflated operational debt claims, casting doubt on the bona fide nature of the application.
The NCLAT emphasized that the initiation of insolvency proceedings under the guise of restructuring cannot be a shield for fraudulent or malicious intent. It reiterated that full and truthful disclosure of liabilities is mandatory in a Section 10 application to provide the adjudicating authority with a complete financial picture of the corporate debtor. The tribunal held that the concealment of the decree was deliberate and misleading, amounting to abuse of the insolvency process.
Further, the tribunal dismissed the argument that procedural lapses in director appointments and form filings under the Companies Act, 2013, could validate the initiation of CIRP. The absence of a valid board meant no proper authorization for the insolvency application, rendering the proceedings void ab initio.
Regarding the resolution plan approved by Sonoma Management Partners, the tribunal clarified that such a plan is binding only after approval by the adjudicating authority under Section 31 of the IBC. Since the CIRP itself was found to be fraudulently initiated and thus recalled, the resolution plan approval by the Committee of Creditors held no legal effect. The tribunal refused to allow continuation of the CIRP on consent or to reinitiate it at an advanced stage, as the fraudulent inception vitiated the entire process.
A penalty of ₹5,00,000 was imposed on Intarvo Technologies under Section 65(1) of the IBC for fraudulent and malicious initiation of proceedings. The tribunal directed the discharge of the resolution professional and restoration of the corporate debtor's management and banking operations to the status prevailing before CIRP commencement.
The judgment underscores the judiciary's firm stance against misuse of the insolvency resolution process and reinforces the importance of transparency and lawful corporate governance in insolvency proceedings. It sends a strong message that fraudulent concealment and unauthorized corporate actions will not be tolerated and will attract strict penalties, including recall of insolvency proceedings and financial sanctions.
Bottom Line:
Fraudulent or malicious initiation of proceedings under Section 10 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, can lead to recall of the admission order, termination of CIRP, restoration of the corporate debtor to its pre-CIRP position, and imposition of penalties under Section 65 of the Code.
Statutory provision(s):
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 Sections 10, 31, 60(5), 61(1), 65; Companies Act, 2013 Sections 172, 176