Tribunal holds that mere association with companies listed as wilful defaulters does not disqualify an individual under Section 29A(b) of IBC; MSME promoter's exclusion from resolution process set aside for lack of independent proof of wilful defaulter status.
In a landmark decision dated October 28, 2026, the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Bengaluru Bench, in the matter of V.V.S.R. Anjaneyulu Vattem v. Gullapalli Kishore Babu & Another, ruled in favor of an erstwhile promoter and suspended director of a corporate debtor registered as a Micro, Small and Medium Enterprise (MSME), reversing his exclusion from the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP).
The applicant, Mr. V.V.S.R. Anjaneyulu Vattem, challenged his disqualification from the list of Prospective Resolution Applicants (PRAs) by the Resolution Professional (RP) and Committee of Creditors (CoC) on the ground that he was allegedly a wilful defaulter under Section 29A(b) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 ("IBC"), due to his association as director with two companies - M/s Karnataka Cements Limited and M/s Sri Chakra Financial Services - listed as wilful defaulters in RBI records.
Mr. Vattem contended that the wilful defaulter tag was attributed to the companies and not to him personally, and that the loans in question pertained to periods before his directorship or were disputed and sub judice. He further relied on Section 240A of the IBC, which grants MSME promoters exemption from certain disqualifications under Section 29A, notably clauses (c) and (h). The applicant asserted that no conclusive evidence or RBI order existed declaring him a wilful defaulter in his individual capacity, and that the RP's reliance on CIBIL and public records without independent verification was erroneous and contrary to principles of natural justice.
The Resolution Professional and Maximus ARC, a CoC member, resisted the application, relying on RBI's wilful defaulter classification of the companies with which the applicant was associated, and citing the NCLAT judgment in Namdev Hindurao Patil v. Virendra Kumar Jain (2023), which emphasized that MSME exemptions do not extend to Section 29A(b) relating to wilful defaulters. They argued that the CoC's commercial wisdom could not override statutory disqualifications and that the RP's verification duties required exclusion of the applicant based on the available wilful defaulter data.
The NCLT Bench, consisting of Shri Sunil Kumar Aggarwal, Member (Judicial), and Shri Radhakrishna Sreepada, Member (Technical), undertook a detailed examination of Section 29A and Section 240A of the IBC. The Tribunal highlighted the statutory requirement that wilful defaulter status under Section 29A(b) must be established in the individual capacity of the person concerned, not merely by association with companies listed as wilful defaulters. The Bench observed that the applicant was not independently classified as a wilful defaulter, and the purported wilful defaulter records related only to the companies. It emphasized the need for RP to verify eligibility beyond mechanical reliance on databases and underscored the legislative intent to protect MSME promoters to aid revival and resolution.
Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the RP's decision excluding the applicant from the final list of PRAs and directed his inclusion, subject to compliance with other eligibility conditions. The proposed consortium participation with M/s Aikyam Stressed Assets Fund-I was also allowed pending independent eligibility verification of all members.
This ruling reinforces the principle that statutory disqualifications under the IBC, especially related to wilful defaulters, require clear and independent evidence against the individual and cannot be inferred solely from corporate associations. It affirms MSME promoters' protection under the Code and underscores the procedural safeguards around eligibility verification by the RP and the CoC.
Bottom Line:
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 - An erstwhile promoter and suspended director of a Corporate Debtor classified as a director in companies listed as "wilful defaulters" cannot be excluded from the list of Prospective Resolution Applicants under Section 29A(b) unless evidence substantiates their independent ineligibility in individual capacity as a wilful defaulter.
Statutory provision(s):
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 Sections 29A(b), 29A(c), 29A(h), 240A, 25(2)(h); IBBI (CIRP) Regulations, 2016 Regulation 36A; RBI (Commercial Banks-Treatment of Wilful Defaulters and Large Defaulters) Directions, 2025