Tribunal confirms jurisdiction based on registered office of Bhushan Power & Steel Ltd., validates Central Government's opinion formation under Companies Act, and rejects multiple procedural challenges
The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Principal Bench, New Delhi, delivered a comprehensive order on October 30, 2026, affirming the maintainability of a petition filed by the Union of India through the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO) against Bhushan Power and Steel Limited (BPSL) and 75 other respondents. The petition, filed under Sections 241(2), 242, 246 read with Section 339 of the Companies Act, 2013, alleges fraudulent conduct and mismanagement in the affairs of BPSL, seeking orders including disgorgement of assets and personal liability for fraud amounting to approximately Rs. 5,431 crore.
Territorial Jurisdiction Affirmed
The Tribunal held that the territorial jurisdiction for petitions under Section 241(2) of the Companies Act is determined by the registered office of the "concerned company" whose affairs are under scrutiny. Since BPSL's registered office is in New Delhi, the Principal Bench rightly exercises jurisdiction, notwithstanding that many other entities arrayed as respondents have registered offices outside its territorial jurisdiction. These entities were impleaded as necessary and proper parties alleged to have knowingly participated or benefited from the fraudulent conduct involving BPSL.
Single Petition Against Multiple Entities Maintained
Rejecting objections that the petition improperly aggregates multiple independent companies, the Tribunal emphasized that the petition concerns the affairs of a single company, BPSL, and other respondents are arrayed only for their alleged knowing participation in the fraud. The Tribunal referred to the General Clauses Act, 1897, which allows singular words to include the plural, and to principles of joinder under Order I Rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Code, permitting joined defendants where relief arises from the same transactions or questions of fact.
Central Government's Opinion Formation Validated
A key challenge was the contention that the Central Government had not independently formed the requisite opinion to initiate proceedings under Section 241(2). The Tribunal held that the letter dated May 19, 2022, issued by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA), evidencing sanction and authorization to the SFIO to file the petition, constitutes valid formation of opinion by the Central Government on relevant material, namely the SFIO's investigation report dated May 6, 2022. The subjective nature of such opinion was acknowledged, but the Tribunal underscored the need for the opinion to be based on relevant facts and not be arbitrary, which was satisfied here.
Petition Properly Instituted by Central Government
It was also contended that the petition was filed by the SFIO and not by the Central Government itself, thus lacking statutory authority. The Tribunal distinguished between delegation and authorization, holding that the Central Government had authorized the SFIO to present the petition on its behalf, which is a ministerial act and does not require formal delegation under Section 458 of the Companies Act. The petition was filed in the name of the Union of India, and the SFIO merely acts as the authorized representative.
Scope of "Are Being Conducted" Includes Past Acts with Continuing Effect
Respondents argued that Section 241(2) applies only to ongoing conduct and excludes past transactions. The Tribunal rejected this narrow interpretation, holding that, read with Sections 242 and 246 and Section 339 (applied mutatis mutandis), "are being conducted" includes past acts or transactions that have continuing prejudicial effects, such as the retention of diverted assets or funds. The completion of BPSL's insolvency resolution and replacement of management did not end the continuing prejudice caused by the alleged fraudulent conduct.
Application of Section 339 and Wide Powers under Section 242
The Tribunal affirmed that Section 339, which imposes personal liability for fraudulent conduct of business, applies mutatis mutandis to petitions under Section 241. Although Section 339 refers to winding up, the Tribunal held it applicable even though BPSL was resolved as a going concern under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), given the statutory cross-application. The Tribunal's powers under Section 242 are wide and include disgorgement, restoration, freezing of assets, and imposition of personal liability.
Section 212(14A) Is an Additional, Not Exclusive, Remedy
The Tribunal rejected the submission that Section 212(14A), introduced in 2019, is an exclusive remedy for disgorgement based on SFIO reports. It held that remedies under Chapter XVI (Sections 241, 242, 246 and 339) are independent and available alongside Section 212(14A), and the Central Government may elect the appropriate remedy. The Tribunal relied on binding decisions including a Delhi High Court judgment and the NCLAT judgment in BSR & Associates LLP v. SFIO.
Proceedings Pending Before Delhi High Court Do Not Bar Petition
Certain writ petitions challenging the investigation, sanction, and assignment of investigation to SFIO are pending before the Delhi High Court. The Tribunal held that the pendency of such proceedings does not bar maintainability or adjudication of the petition before the NCLT, particularly as the High Court Division Bench has permitted this Tribunal to proceed subject to further directions.
Petition Not Barred by Limitation
Applying Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963, the Tribunal held the three-year limitation period runs from the date when the Central Government is in a position to form the opinion under Section 241(2). The right to apply accrued only after the SFIO report was submitted in 2022, and thus the petition filed in April 2023 is within the limitation period. Further, Section 17 of the Limitation Act postpones limitation till the discovery of fraud, which was only clearly established in 2022.
Parallel Proceedings Under IBC Do Not Bar Petition
The Tribunal rejected the objection that parallel proceedings under Section 66 of the IBC by the Resolution Professional bar the present petition on grounds of double jeopardy, res sub judice or lis pendens. It held that the statutory basis, reliefs, and applicants differ, and the remedies are independent. Concerns regarding conflicting findings and double recovery will be addressed through case management and appropriate credits.
Impleading of Persons against Whom Fraud Is Alleged Necessary
The Tribunal emphasized that persons against whom personal allegations of fraud are levelled must be impleaded by name and given a fair opportunity to be heard, in line with natural justice. This justifies joinder of various entities and individuals as respondents.
Interim Orders to Continue
Interim orders restraining respondents from alienating or disposing of their movable and immovable properties, and freezing bank accounts, passed initially on June 8, 2023, and subsequently extended, shall continue until further orders.
Next Steps and Directions
The Tribunal directed the respondents to file replies on merits and furnish statements identifying roles in the alleged fraud. It also required disclosure of transactions covered by pending IBC proceedings and ordered credit to be given for amounts recovered to avoid double recovery. The petition is listed for further proceedings on November 26, 2026.
Conclusion
The NCLT Principal Bench's detailed order confirms the maintainability of the Central Government's petition against BPSL and associated entities for alleged fraud and mismanagement. The decision clarifies jurisdictional principles, procedural requirements, and the scope of statutory powers, while rejecting procedural and substantive preliminary objections raised by respondents. The order sets the stage for substantive adjudication on the merits of one of the largest fraud-related company law proceedings in recent times.
Bottom Line:
Petition by Union of India through SFIO under Sections 241(2), 242, 246 and 339 of the Companies Act, 2013 against persons/entities allegedly involved in fraudulent conduct of affairs of BPSL is maintainable before NCLT Principal Bench, New Delhi; Section 212(14A) is an additional remedy and does not bar recourse to Chapter XVI.
Statutory provision(s):
Sections 241(2), 242, 246, 339, 212(14A), 219(d), 419, 458 of the Companies Act, 2013; Sections 25(2)(j), 43, 45, 49, 50, 66 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016; Sections 20, 79, Order I Rule 3 and Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Section 13(2) of the General Clauses Act, 1897; Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963.