Court Rules Candidates Cannot Challenge Selection Criteria Post Participation Without Alleging Malafide or Constitutional Violation
In a significant judgment dated November 3, 2026, the Punjab and Haryana High Court, presided over by Justice Nidhi Gupta, dismissed a writ petition filed by Navdeep Kaur challenging the final result of the Assistant District Attorney (Group-B) recruitment conducted by the Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC).
The petitioner, Navdeep Kaur, who participated in the recruitment process for 255 posts, contested the arbitrary marks awarded to her during the interview stage, alleging a lack of transparency and violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. She sought quashing of the final result dated October 22, 2026, production of detailed interview evaluation records, and a directive for a fresh interview before a differently constituted board under a transparent and recorded process.
The Court meticulously examined the sequence of events where the petitioner had cleared the Screening Test and the Subject Knowledge Test (SKT) and had also undergone document verification and interview. Despite her participation, she was not selected. The petitioner contended that the interview marks awarded to her (4.24 out of 12.5) were arbitrary and unreasoned and highlighted the absence of pre-disclosed criteria or parameters for the interview evaluation.
Rejecting the petitioner's arguments, the Court relied on authoritative Supreme Court precedents, including Mohit Kumar v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Madan Lal v. State of J & K, emphasizing that a candidate who participates in a selection process without raising objections cannot later challenge the process unless there is a demonstrable violation of constitutional rights or mala fide conduct.
The judgment underscored that the Court is not an appellate authority to reassess the subjective evaluation of candidates by an expert interview committee. It reiterated that judicial interference in recruitment matters is limited to instances of procedural irregularity or malafide action, neither of which were established by the petitioner.
Furthermore, the Court noted the absence of any allegation or evidence of bias or mala fide conduct against the Interview Board. It emphasized that the candidate's dissatisfaction with the outcome does not translate into legal grounds to question the selection process.
Consequently, the writ petition was dismissed, reinforcing the principle that recruitment and selection processes, once participated in without protest, are binding on the candidates.
This judgment provides clarity on the limitations of judicial intervention in recruitment processes and upholds the sanctity of expert committee assessments in public service appointments, provided constitutional safeguards are maintained.
Bottom Line:
A candidate who participates in a selection process without raising any objection cannot later challenge the selection criteria or process after being unsuccessful, unless there is a breach of Articles 14 or 16 of the Constitution of India.
Statutory provision(s):
Articles 14, 16, 226, 227 of the Constitution of India
Navdeep Kaur v. State of Haryana, (Punjab And Haryana) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3033562