Court emphasizes that repair or renovation work on disputed property requires prior permission, dismissing respondents' plea of bonafide repair as insufficient to excuse disobedience.
In a significant ruling delivered on November 4, 2026, the Rajasthan High Court, presided over by Justice Sandeep Shah, held the respondents guilty of contempt of court for deliberately and willfully disobeying an interim status quo order pertaining to a property dispute. The contempt petition was filed by Devendra and others against the legal representatives of Magni and others, alleging unauthorized construction activities on a disputed plot despite a standing court order.
The case arose out of an order dated November 29, 1999, in S.B. Civil Second Appeal No. 360/1999, where the Court had directed the parties to maintain status quo over the property in question. This interim order remained in force, with the second appeal pending adjudication for over two decades. The petitioners brought to the Court's attention recent photographs showing that the respondents had undertaken construction work on the disputed land without prior judicial approval.
The respondents contended that the work was limited to repairing an existing dilapidated room on the site, undertaken in good faith without the intention to violate the Court's order. They claimed the delay in proceedings had led to their inability to regularly consult legal counsel and expressed unconditional apology for the inadvertent breach.
However, the Court rejected these contentions, emphasizing that the interim order unequivocally barred any construction or renovation activities without the Court's permission. It pointed out that even during exceptional circumstances such as the COVID-19 pandemic, the Court remained functional and entertained applications for modification or permission to carry out repairs. No such application was filed by the respondents, nor was any permission sought before commencing the work.
Justice Shah observed that the respondents' explanation did not absolve them from liability as the obligation to comply with the status quo order was mandatory and independent of the appeal's progress or counsel availability. The Court found the respondents' actions to be a deliberate and willful disobedience of its order.
While holding the respondents guilty of contempt, the Court granted them an opportunity to show cause and make submissions regarding the punishment before imposing any penalties. The matter has been scheduled for further hearing on November 25, 2026, to decide on the question of punishment.
This judgment underscores the judiciary's strict stance on adherence to interim orders in civil disputes and the necessity of obtaining prior judicial sanction before undertaking any changes to the status quo, even if such changes are presented as repair or renovation.
Bottom Line:
Contempt of Court - Respondents held guilty of contempt for deliberate and wilful disobedience of a court's order to maintain status quo regarding disputed property. Repair or renovation work cannot be undertaken without prior permission from the court during the subsistence of an interim order.
Statutory provision(s):
Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, Section 2(b), Section 12
Devendra v. Lrs of Magni, (Rajasthan) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3019147