LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Tripura High Court Upholds Rejection of Candidate's Age Relaxation Claim in Recruitment Process

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Tripura High Court Upholds Rejection of Candidate's Age Relaxation Claim in Recruitment Process

Court Rules Documentary Proof Mandatory for Age Relaxation; Mere Token of Participation Insufficient in Canceled Recruitment Case


In a significant judgment delivered on October 14, 2026, the Tripura High Court dismissed a writ petition filed by Sri Nayan Kumar Dhar challenging the rejection of his candidature for the post of Lower Division Clerk (LDC)/Agriculture Assistant in the recent recruitment conducted by the Joint Recruitment Board of Tripura (JRBT). The petitioner had sought a one-time upper age relaxation on the ground that he had participated in an earlier recruitment process for the same post which was allegedly canceled.


The petitioner had produced a token as evidence of his participation in the earlier recruitment process notified on September 25, 2018, by the Department of Agriculture. Claiming that this recruitment was canceled, he sought age relaxation benefits provided under the government's recruitment policy dated August 20, 2018, which allowed relaxation for candidates who participated in canceled recruitments upon furnishing documentary proof.


However, the Court observed that the advertisement dated September 25, 2018, was issued after the new recruitment policy came into force and there was no documentary proof or official communication from the Department of Agriculture that this particular recruitment process was canceled. The Court held that the one-time age relaxation benefit was strictly available only to candidates who could demonstrate through documentary evidence that the earlier recruitment process had been canceled. Mere production of a participation token without such proof was insufficient.


The judgment further noted that the petitioner's date of birth made him overage as per the recruitment notification dated February 12, 2021, and despite securing higher marks than some selected candidates, his candidature was rejected solely due to over-age criteria. The Court emphasized that it was incumbent on the petitioner to obtain and produce clear documentary evidence, possibly by utilizing the Right to Information Act, to prove the cancellation of the earlier recruitment notification. The failure to do so justified the rejection of his claim.


The Tripura High Court thus upheld the JRBT's decision to exclude the petitioner from the merit list and refused to issue any mandamus directing his inclusion or a republication of the merit list. The writ petition was dismissed for lack of merit.


This ruling clarifies the strict evidentiary requirements for claiming age relaxation benefits in government recruitments and underscores the importance of documentary proof in cases involving canceled recruitment processes.


Bottom Line:

Recruitment - One-time upper age relaxation for candidates who participated in cancelled recruitment process - Candidate claiming relaxation must produce documentary proof that earlier recruitment process for same post was cancelled - Mere production of token showing participation in earlier selection process is insufficient - Where advertisement relied upon by petitioner was issued after new recruitment policy and no material was produced to show its cancellation, rejection of candidature on ground of over-age held proper.


Statutory provision(s):

General Recruitment Policy dated 20.08.2018 (Government Memorandum), Advertisement Notifications dated 25.09.2018 and 12.02.2021, Right to Information Act (implied)


Sri Nayan Kumar Dhar v. State of Tripura, (Tripura) : Law Finder Doc Id # 2999250

Share this article: