Court rules acquisition of land under Maharashtra Industrial Development Act for private company Maharishi Vedoddharak Foundation was a colourable exercise of power, violating public purpose doctrine and agreements with Tata Power.
In a landmark judgment dated November 5, 2026, the Bombay High Court (Division Bench comprising Justices Manish Pitale and Shreeram V. Shirsat) quashed the Maharashtra State Government's notification and related proceedings initiated under the Maharashtra Industrial Development Act, 1961 (MID Act) that sought to acquire approximately 84 hectares of land belonging to Tata Power Company Ltd. (TPCL) for the benefit of Maharishi Vedoddharak Foundation (MVF), a private entity.
The land in question forms part of the Thokarwadi Dam and reservoir area in Pune district, which has been in the possession of TPCL's predecessor since acquisition between 1911 and 1940 under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 for the public purpose of establishing hydroelectric power projects. The High Court held that the impugned acquisition was illegal, mala fide, and a colourable exercise of power, as it sought to acquire land already utilized for public purpose and hand it over to a private company through a `pass through' method under the MID Act, bypassing the procedural safeguards under the general land acquisition law, including the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (Act of 2013).
The Court emphasized that while the State possesses the inherent power of eminent domain to acquire land for public purposes, such power is not unbridled and must be exercised strictly in accordance with law and for genuine public purpose. The judgment clarified that the MID Act is a special statute aimed at developing industrial estates and industrial areas and does not contemplate acquisition solely for a private company's benefit. The acquisition in this case was found to be primarily for private interest, despite claims of ancillary public benefits such as employment generation.
Key Findings:
1. The agreements and conveyances executed over a century ago between TPCL's predecessor and the Government clearly stipulated that the State could reclaim any unutilized land only if it was no longer needed for the hydroelectric project and for public purposes like revenue administration, safety, or health. The land sought to be acquired was still actively used for the existing 75 MW Bhivpuri Hydro Station and the proposed 1000 MW Bhivpuri Pumped Storage Project, confirmed by a Memorandum of Understanding between TPCL and the State dated August 8, 2023.
2. The State and MIDC's claim that the land was unutilized was neither stated in the acquisition notification nor supported by any prior enquiry, and such a post-hoc justification in affidavits was rejected by the Court.
3. The `pass through' method employed under Section 39(1)(a) of the MID Act to acquire and dispose of the land directly to MVF, a private company, without following the stringent provisions applicable under the general land acquisition laws for companies, was held impermissible and amounted to bypassing statutory safeguards.
4. The High Power Committee (HPC) of the State had earlier rejected the acquisition proposal on policy grounds, which was then overruled by the Cabinet Sub-Committee in a pre-determined manner to favor MVF, indicating mala fide intent and colourable exercise of power.
5. The Court held that the acquisition was not for a primary public purpose since the land was already devoted to a hydroelectric project serving the public, and MVF's project was primarily private with incidental public benefits. The acquisition violated Article 300A of the Constitution, which protects property rights subject to lawful acquisition for public purpose.
6. Writ petition was held maintainable despite pending show cause proceedings before the Sub-Divisional Officer (SDO), as the latter's proceedings were pre-determined and could not effectively adjudicate constitutional challenges.
7. All impugned notifications dated March 3 and 4, 2025, and show cause notices dated March 7, 2025, were quashed, and acquisition proceedings were set aside.
Impact and Significance:
This judgment underscores the constitutional safeguards in land acquisition, particularly for land already acquired for public purposes. It clarifies that special statutes like the MID Act cannot be used as a backdoor to acquire land for private entities bypassing procedural rigors and principles of public purpose. The ruling protects property rights under Article 300A and affirms that State's sovereign power of eminent domain is subject to legal and constitutional limitations.
The judgment sends a strong message against mala fide actions and colourable exercises of power by authorities and reinforces the requirement of transparency, fairness, and bona fide public purpose in land acquisitions. It also highlights the importance of following prescribed statutory procedures and respecting agreements and conveyances concerning land use.
Bottom Line:
Maharashtra Industrial Development Act, 1961 - State cannot invoke MID Act to acquire land already acquired and utilized for public purpose of hydro electric projects, solely to hand it over to a private company for its ultra mega project - Such acquisition by "pass through" method amounts to colourable exercise of power and mala fide action - MID Act does not contemplate acquisition for a private company in the manner provided under general land acquisition law.
Statutory provision(s): Maharashtra Industrial Development Act, 1961 Sections 1(3), 2(g), 2(h), 32, 39; Land Acquisition Act, 1894 Sections 38-44B, 40, 41; Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 Sections 2, 10A; Constitution of India Article 300A
Tata Power Company Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra, (Bombay)(DB) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3013824