Court holds that mere delay in pronouncing arbitral award is insufficient ground for setting it aside but finds award unreasoned and invalid only as far as guarantor is concerned, waiving late objections on arbitrator appointment.
In a significant judgment dated October 29, 2026, the Bombay High Court, presided over by Justice Arun R. Pedneker, partially set aside an arbitral award in the case of Manish Mehta v. India Cements Capital & Finance Limited. The case concerned a Hire Purchase Agreement and the liability of Manish Mehta as guarantor for a loan extended by India Cements Capital & Finance Limited (Respondent No. 1) to another party (Respondent No. 2).
The arbitral proceedings had been invoked in 2003, with the award reserved in January 2008 but pronounced only in August 2012 - a delay of over four and a half years. Manish Mehta challenged the award under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, contending that the delay, combined with the arbitrator's failure to adequately consider his specific defences as guarantor, rendered the award unreasoned and hence liable to be set aside.
Key issues before the Court included whether the arbitrator was appointed in accordance with the contract terms, whether the delay in pronouncement affected the award's validity, and whether the arbitrator sufficiently dealt with the guarantor's defences under Sections 133 and 139 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
The Court held that objections to the arbitrator's appointment not raised timely before submission of the statement of defence amounted to waiver, referencing Sections 4 and 16 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act and prior case law including State of Maharashtra v. Morya Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. Thus, Manish Mehta's late challenge to the arbitrator's appointment was barred.
Regarding the delay, the Court acknowledged that delay alone is not an independent ground to set aside an award. Citing the Supreme Court's decision in M/s. Lancor Holdings Limited v. Prem Kumar Menon (2025), the Court emphasized that the impact of delay must be examined on a case-by-case basis to determine if it impaired the arbitrator's ability to properly evaluate evidence and arguments.
In this case, the Court found that the arbitrator failed to address crucial defences raised by the guarantor, including that the creditor's alteration of contract terms without the guarantor's consent (Section 133) and conduct impairing the guarantor's remedy (Section 139) had discharged the guarantor's liability. The award merely recorded the guarantor's contentions but did not provide reasoned findings thereon, rendering it virtually unreasoned and affected by the delay.
Importantly, since the award was challenged only by the guarantor and not the principal borrower, the Court invoked the principle of severability. Following the Supreme Court's ruling in Gayatri Balasamy v. ISG Novasoft Technologies Limited (2025), the Court set aside the award only to the extent it applied to the guarantor. The award remains binding on the borrower.
This judgment underscores the necessity for arbitral tribunals to diligently address all parties' defences and the time sensitivity of raising objections to tribunal composition. It also affirms that delay in pronouncement, while serious, must be shown to affect the fairness or reasoned nature of the award to justify interference.
Bottom Line:
Arbitration - Section 34 petition by guarantor - Mere delay in pronouncing arbitral award is not by itself a ground to set aside award, but where award was delivered more than four and a half years after being reserved and failed to deal with guarantor's specific defences under Sections 133 and 139 of Contract Act, award held virtually unreasoned and liable to be set aside only qua guarantor - Objection to appointment/composition of arbitral tribunal, if not raised in time under Sections 16 and 4 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, stands waived.
Statutory provision(s):
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Sections 4, 10, 13, 16, 21, 31(3), 34, 37; Indian Contract Act, 1872 Sections 133, 139; Maharashtra Stamp Act Section 52B
Manish Mehta v. India Cements Capital & Finance Limited, (Bombay) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3006298