LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Calcutta High Court Dismisses Writ Petition Seeking Enquiry into Unauthorized Demolition of Bookstall

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Calcutta High Court Dismisses Writ Petition Seeking Enquiry into Unauthorized Demolition of Bookstall

Court Rules No Fundamental Right Violated as Petitioner Erected Temporary Bookstall Without Permission; Advises Pursuit of Other Legal Remedies


In a recent judgment delivered on November 10, 2026, the Calcutta High Court, presided over by Justice Rishad Medora, dismissed a writ petition filed by the Association for Protection of Democratic Rights (APDR) seeking an independent and time-bound enquiry into the unauthorized demolition of a temporary bookstall. The bookstall had been erected by the petitioner without obtaining the requisite permission from the concerned authorities.


The petitioner had constructed the temporary bookstall on October 17, 2026, assuming that no objection would be raised due to the silence of authorities on its application for permission. However, the structure was demolished on October 19, 2026, under circumstances unknown to the petitioner. In response, APDR filed a writ petition demanding an enquiry and compensation for the loss and injury suffered.


The Court carefully examined the facts, including the petitioner's failure to obtain official sanction before erecting the bookstall. It observed that the petitioner's fundamental rights were not infringed upon by the demolition, as the construction was unauthorized. The Court further noted that the petitioner's representation dated October 21, 2026, seeking redressal had not been considered by the authorities. However, it declined to issue any direction for enquiry or compensation, emphasizing that the petitioner was free to pursue other legal remedies available under the law.


Rejecting the writ petition, Justice Medora underscored that in the absence of a violation of fundamental rights, the High Court's writ jurisdiction could not be invoked. The judgment clarified that the petitioner's assumption that silence by authorities equated to permission was misplaced. The Court also pointed out that no affidavit was called for from the respondents, so the allegations in the petition remained unadmitted.


The writ petition was dismissed without any order as to costs. The Court directed that certified copies of the order be supplied expeditiously upon compliance with formalities and reminded all parties to act on the basis of the official server copy of the judgment.


This ruling serves as a reminder that erecting structures in public spaces without prior permission from competent authorities is not protected under fundamental rights and may attract lawful demolition. It also highlights the importance of following due process and exhausting statutory remedies before approaching courts through writ petitions.


Bottom Line:

A writ petition seeking an enquiry into unauthorized demolition of a temporary bookstall erected without permission was dismissed. The Court held that no fundamental right of the petitioner was violated, and the petitioner was at liberty to pursue other remedies available under the law.


Statutory provision(s):

Constitution of India Article 226


Association for Protection of Democratic Rights (APDR) v. State of West Bengal, (Calcutta) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3018753

Share this article: