Court holds that foreign litigation on Indian copyright claims is oppressive and vexatious, affirming that Indian law governs copyright subsistence and exceptions in broadcasts created and published in India.
In a landmark decision dated November 5, 2026, the Delhi High Court, presided over by Justice Tejas Karia, granted an anti-suit injunction in favor of T.V. Today Network Limited, a prominent Indian broadcaster, restraining several US-based defendants from pursuing copyright infringement claims in a United States District Court. The injunction bars the defendants from continuing proceedings in the US and from initiating any other foreign legal actions that pertain to the same subject matter as the ongoing suit in India.
The dispute arose when Global Weather Productions LLC and associated defendants filed a lawsuit in the Northern District of California alleging copyright infringement involving weather-related footage used by T.V. Today Network in its news broadcasts. The Plaintiff contended that the broadcasts, including scripted narration, editing, and compilation, were created and published entirely in India for an Indian audience, with all relevant personnel and evidence located in India. The Plaintiff further asserted that the copyright claims were governed exclusively by Indian law under the Copyright Act, 1957.
Notably, the Plaintiff's use of the footage fell under the fair dealing exception as per Section 52(1)(a)(iii) of the Copyright Act, which exempts use of short extracts for news reporting. The Court observed that natural weather events depicted in the footage were universal facts not subject to copyright protection. Additionally, the use was deemed de minimis-trivial to the extent that no legal action should be entertained-as supported by precedent in Associated Broadcasting Company Limited v. Google LLC (2026) and India TV Independent News Service Pvt. Ltd. v. Yashraj Films Pvt. Ltd. (2012).
The Court emphasized that the Plaintiff had no commercial presence or business operations in the US, and the sole US connection was the use of YouTube, a platform owned by Defendant No. 7, which imposed a non-negotiable jurisdiction clause in its copyright counter-notification procedure. The Court held that this unilateral jurisdiction clause could not override the fact that the cause of action arose entirely in India and was governed by Indian law.
Applying Supreme Court precedents including Oil and Natural Gas Commission v. Western Company of North America (1987) and HT Media Limited v. Brainlink International, Inc. (2020), the Court found the US proceedings oppressive and vexatious. The continuation of the US suit risked conflicting decisions and unfairly subjected the Plaintiff to foreign law for acts committed in India. The balance of convenience and the interests of justice favored the Plaintiff, who would suffer irreparable harm if forced to litigate in the US.
Consequently, the Delhi High Court ordered that until the final disposal of the Indian suit, the defendants and their agents are restrained from proceeding with the US litigation or instituting any foreign proceedings concerning the same matter. The Court clarified that the injunction is in personam and does not question the jurisdiction of the US Court over other parties.
This decision reinforces the principle that Indian courts can exercise jurisdiction to protect domestic parties from oppressive foreign litigation, particularly where the dispute arises from acts performed in India and governed by Indian statutes. It also affirms the scope of fair dealing in news reporting under Indian copyright law, especially in relation to factual and public interest content such as weather events.
Bottom Line:
Anti-suit injunction granted to restrain foreign proceedings where the dispute arises from acts in India, governed by Indian law, and adjudication abroad would be oppressive and vexatious.
Statutory provision(s):
Copyright Act, 1957 Section 52(1)(a)(iii), Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2, Section 151; Digital Millennium Copyright Act, 1998 (DMCA)
T.V.Today Network Limited v. Global Weather Productions LLC, (Delhi) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3018735