Court reprimands Collector for exceeding jurisdiction by probing land title in NA permission case; directs fresh decision within statutory period, emphasizing respect for judicial orders
In a significant judgment delivered on November 5, 2026, the Gujarat High Court, presided over by Mrs. M. K. Thakker, quashed the order dated August 6, 2026, passed by the Collector of Ahmedabad rejecting Bhumikaben's application for Non-Agricultural (NA) land use permission under Section 65 of the Gujarat Land Revenue Code, 1879. The Court observed that the Collector had acted beyond his statutory jurisdiction by examining the title of the land and relying on negative opinions related to tenancy permissions under the Tenancy Act, which are not grounds for rejection under Section 65.
The petitioner, Bhumikaben, had initially applied for NA permission on April 7, 2026, following directions from the High Court in a prior writ petition (Special Civil Application No. 3097 of 2025), which had set aside an earlier rejection dated February 11, 2025. The High Court had clarified that the Collector's role under Section 65 is limited to verifying the applicant's occupancy and the agricultural nature of the land, without delving into title disputes. Despite this, the Collector again rejected the fresh application citing the same grounds, including the absence of permission under Section 63 of the Tenancy Act and ongoing civil disputes regarding the title.
The Court reiterated the principle from the Supreme Court's ruling in State of Gujarat v. Patel Raghav Natha, (1969) 2 SCC 187, that when title disputes exist, the Collector is not empowered to decide them but should refer the parties to a competent civil court. It also relied on the Gujarat High Court's own precedent in Tusharbhai Harjibhai Ghelani v. State of Gujarat, (2019) 4 GLR 2578, which underscored that NA permission applications involve a summary inquiry into occupancy and land use, not a title adjudication.
Highlighting the repeated disregard of court orders and statutory timelines, the High Court held that the Collector's conduct amounted to arbitrary and flagrant violation of judicial directions. The Court imposed an exemplary cost of Rs. 1,00,000 on the Collector to be paid from his salary, with the State directed to recover the amount if the Collector defaults. This cost is to be disbursed to the petitioner as compensation for the hardship caused.
The Court ordered the restoration of the petitioner's application to the Collector's file and directed that it be decided within the statutory 90-day period strictly in accordance with the legal principles laid down by the Court. The judgment serves as a stern reminder to government authorities about the need to respect judicial orders and act within the bounds of their statutory powers, emphasizing the importance of judicial discipline and expeditious decision-making in public administration.
Bottom Line:
Non-Agricultural (NA) land use permission under Section 65 of the Gujarat Land Revenue Code - Collector cannot exceed the statutory jurisdiction by examining the title of the land while deciding NA permissions - Repeated rejections contrary to court directions held arbitrary and violative of judicial orders - Exemplary cost imposed on the Collector for disobedience.
Statutory provision(s): Gujarat Land Revenue Code, 1879 Section 65, Tenancy Act Section 63
Bhumikaben v. Collector, Ahmedabad, (Gujarat) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3018736