Court directs strict adherence to transparent book procurement policies, orders registration of FIR against officials, and mandates corrective measures to uphold public trust and cultural integrity
Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court (Division Bench) delivered a landmark judgment on 10th November 2026 addressing the alarming fraudulent practices in the procurement of books for public libraries across Tamil Nadu. The case, initiated by petitioner Ramasubbu against K. Gopal, IAS, and others, uncovered a deeply entrenched scam involving the purchase of books with dubious content, plagiarism, and false authorship that has compromised the integrity of public libraries.
The court recalled its earlier directions issued on 19th June 2024 in the matter of public library book procurement, which mandated transparency, public notification, and strict compliance with the Government Order (G.O.) Ms. No. 69, School Education Department, dated 7th March 2024. Despite these directives, the court noted that the procurement process continued to be plagued by irregularities, including re-publication of nationalised books under false titles and authorship, purchase of plagiarised works, and involvement of publishers operating through multiple fronts to secure government orders through unethical means.
Highlighting the cultural and educational significance of libraries, the court emphasized that public libraries are custodians of authentic knowledge and literature, serving as platforms for social justice, empowerment, and preservation of cultural heritage. The judgment underscored the obligation of the State under Entry 12, List-II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India, to maintain high standards in library services and ensure that books procured are of genuine quality and cultural value.
The court expressed serious concern over the breach of moral rights of authors, citing instances where books were falsely attributed to renowned literary figures such as Jean Dreze and Bharathiyar. It observed that such practices not only violate statutory provisions under the Tamil Nadu Public Libraries Act, 1948, but also infringe upon the fundamental right of citizens to receive accurate and quality information under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution.
The court issued stringent directions to the respondents, including:
- Ensuring all book procurements conform to G.O. Ms. No. 69, 2024, with a transparent and publicly accessible procurement portal.
- Publishing notifications and details of books proposed for purchase on a dedicated website, inviting public comments and objections.
- Constituting a committee to investigate all allegations of malpractice and publishing a comprehensive report within five months.
- Taking disciplinary and criminal action against officials involved, including immediate registration of an FIR by the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC).
- Freezing bank accounts of implicated publishers and suspending responsible government officials.
- Removing fraudulent books from public library shelves to protect the reading public.
- Encouraging school educational institutions to include library visits in their curriculum to promote reading habits.
The judgment also recalled earlier judicial observations highlighting the vital role of libraries in society and the necessity for qualified personnel to manage library services effectively. It warned that failure to act decisively may lead Tamil Nadu's public libraries to suffer a fate akin to the historic destruction of the Library of Alexandria.
The court's intervention follows public outcry triggered by writer Perumal Murugan's social media revelations about fraud in book procurement for the Periyar Arivulagam in Coimbatore. The State government has since acknowledged the systemic failure, relieved key officials, and initiated investigations.
This decisive order by the Madras High Court aims to restore public confidence, preserve the cultural and educational mandate of Tamil Nadu's public libraries, and uphold the majesty of the judiciary by ensuring its earlier orders are fully implemented.
Bottom Line:
Procurement of books for public libraries in Tamil Nadu must adhere to transparent policies to prevent fraudulent practices. Public interest should be the core focus, ensuring the inclusion of authentic and quality literature while protecting cultural and literary heritage.
Statutory provision(s):
Tamil Nadu Public Libraries Act, 1948; Tamil Nadu Public Libraries Rules, 1950 (Rule 18(4)); Constitution of India Article 19(1)(a); Entry 12, List-II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India; Prevention of Corruption Act.
Ramasubbu v. K.Gopal, IAS, (Madras)(DB)(Madurai Bench) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3018752