Court restrains two sellers and directs Amazon to delist counterfeit listings, disclose seller details, and preserve genuine product offers of Manash Lifestyle Pvt. Ltd.
The Delhi High Court has granted an ex parte interim injunction in favour of Manash Lifestyle Private Limited, the proprietor of the “ALPS GOODNESS” brand, after finding a prima facie case that two sellers were allegedly using the plaintiff’s trademark, copyright, and trade dress to sell counterfeit products on Amazon.
Justice Vikas Mahajan, while hearing CS(COMM) No. 1180 of 2026, observed that the plaintiff had placed sufficient material to show that the defendants were offering fake “ALPS GOODNESS ROSEMARY WATER” products through genuine product listings on Amazon, thereby misleading consumers and infringing the company’s statutory and common law rights.
According to the plaint, Manash Lifestyle has been using the “ALPS GOODNESS” brand since 2018 for cosmetics and skincare products and holds multiple trademark and copyright registrations in India, besides a trademark registration in the United States. The company told the court that its rosemary water product, launched in 2023, had become a major commercial success and had earned substantial consumer recognition.
The plaintiff alleged that on discovering suspicious listings on Amazon, it placed test orders from sellers identified as defendant nos. 1 and 2. The products delivered were claimed to be counterfeit, with packaging and artwork nearly identical to the original, except for certain errors such as incorrect company details, missing vegetarian symbol, wrong email ID, and other discrepancies. The plaintiff also produced comparison charts and invoices to support its claim.
A further concern before the court was a promotional leaflet found inside one of the allegedly counterfeit packages, which compared “ALPS GOODNESS ROSEMARY WATER” as the “old look” and another product, “BUFF OUT,” as the “new look.” The plaintiff argued that this material falsely suggested a commercial connection and could confuse consumers.
The court noted the plaintiff’s complaint that the counterfeit products were being sold through the genuine Amazon product listings of the brand, and that third-party sellers had accounted for a significant share of sales on the platform. It also took note of the plaintiff’s claim that it temporarily lost access to its brand registry on Amazon after complaining about the sellers, though access was later restored.
Finding that the balance of convenience lay in favour of the plaintiff and that irreparable harm would be caused if relief was withheld, the court restrained defendant nos. 1 and 2, along with their associates, from manufacturing, selling, advertising, distributing, or otherwise dealing in goods bearing the “ALPS GOODNESS” mark or deceptively similar packaging.
The court also specifically restrained the defendants from using or circulating the promotional leaflet describing “BUFF OUT” as a new version or replacement linked to the plaintiff’s product. In addition, Amazon Seller Services Private Limited was directed to immediately delist the counterfeit offers, while ensuring that genuine product listings of the plaintiff and its authorised sellers remained unaffected.
Significantly, the court directed Amazon to disclose the complete registration and KYC details of the two sellers within two weeks of communication of the order. The plaintiff was also granted liberty to bring additional listings or promotional materials to the court’s attention if further infringement was discovered.
The matter has been listed for further proceedings, with the court directing issuance of notice to the defendants and completion of pleadings in due course.
Bottom Line:
Intellectual Property Rights - Plaintiff granted interim injunction to restrain defendants from infringing trademark, copyright, and trade dress of "ALPS GOODNESS" products due to sale of counterfeit goods.
Statutory provision(s): Commercial Courts Act, 2015 Section 12A, Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 CPC, Order XXXIX Rule 3 CPC, Order XI Rule 1(4) CPC, Section 151 CPC, Order I Rule 10 CPC
Manash Lifestyle Private Limited v. Mayur Dhanji Hanat, (Delhi) : Law Finder Doc id # 3033570