Court Rules Arbitrator's Compensation Based on "Guesstimates" Without Cogent Evidence is Patently Illegal; Also Strikes Down Litigation Costs Awarded for Paris Proceedings
In a significant judgment delivered on October 28, 2026, the Delhi High Court partially set aside an arbitral award which had granted Rs. 4 crore compensation to M/s De Dietrich India Private Limited against M/s Intech Brinechem Limited, relating to an engineering contract dispute for a Bromine Plant project in Gujarat. The Court held that the arbitrator's compensation award was based solely on "guesstimates," lacking any objective evidentiary foundation or reasoned methodology, rendering the award patently illegal under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
The arbitration arose from a contract valued at Rs. 53 crores, under which the respondent had undertaken detailed engineering and supply work. The petitioner had paid an advance of Rs. 5.30 crores secured by a bank guarantee. Disputes emerged over alleged defective engineering designs and the respondent's abandonment of work, with both parties blaming each other for project delays and failures. The petitioner encashed the bank guarantee and initiated arbitration.
The learned Sole Arbitrator found that both parties contributed to the contract's failure but nonetheless awarded Rs. 4 crore to the respondent for the work executed, despite rejecting the respondent's detailed counterclaims for damages due to lack of cogent evidence. The arbitrator described the quantum awarded as "guesstimates," justifying compensation on the basis that some layout plans and technical documents had been accepted by the petitioner, and the respondent should not be left remediless.
Challenging this, the petitioner contended that awarding such a huge amount without any documentary proof or a reasoned basis was perverse and beyond the arbitrator's jurisdiction. The petitioner also assailed the award of Rs. 7 lakhs (Euros 8000) towards litigation costs related to proceedings before the Paris Commercial Court, arguing that the arbitrator failed to provide any supported reasoning for this.
The Court extensively analyzed the scope of guesswork in arbitral awards, referencing authoritative precedents including the Division Bench judgments of this Court and the Supreme Court's rulings in Construction & Design Services v. DDA (2015), Associate Builders v. DDA (2015), and Gemini Bay Transcription (2022). It reiterated that while reasonable guesswork is permissible under exceptional circumstances, it must be based on some identifiable material or a discernible line of reasoning connecting the evidence on record to the quantum awarded. A mere "rough and ready" estimate without any rational nexus or evidentiary foundation is impermissible.
Applying this principle, the Court observed that although the arbitrator found the respondent had failed to substantiate its claims, he still awarded Rs. 4 crore without explaining how acceptance of certain layout plans justified such a substantial figure. The absence of any cogent evidence or rational methodology rendered the award arbitrary and violative of Sections 28(2), 28(3), and 34(2)(a) of the Arbitration Act. The Court emphasized that reasons are the heartbeat of a decision and an award must not be based on whims or conjectures.
Regarding the litigation costs awarded for Paris proceedings, the Court held that the arbitrator's reasoning was opaque and failed to justify how the respondent could recover costs that the Paris Court had ordered it to pay. This too amounted to patent illegality.
Consequently, the Court allowed the petition in part, setting aside the Rs. 4 crore compensation and the litigation costs award, while leaving the other findings of the arbitral award undisturbed.
This judgment underscores the vital requirement that arbitral tribunals must ground their compensation awards on a reasonable evidentiary basis and provide reasoned conclusions, thereby reinforcing the limited scope of judicial interference under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.
Bottom Line:
Arbitration - Award of compensation based on guesswork - Arbitrator must identify cogent evidence or provide a reasoned basis for the quantum awarded. An estimation must rest upon an objective foundation to justify the amount determined.
Statutory provision(s):
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Sections 28(2), 28(3), 34, 34(2)(a)