Court finds reasonable doubt regarding penetration in POCSO case; sentence reduced from 20 years to 5 years rigorous imprisonment
In a significant judgment delivered on November 6, 2026, the Gauhati High Court (Division Bench) modified the conviction and sentence of Bishal Thapa, who was earlier sentenced to 20 years rigorous imprisonment for aggravated penetrative sexual assault under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012. The Court altered the charge from Section 6 (aggravated penetrative sexual assault) to Section 10 (aggravated sexual assault) of the POCSO Act, thereby reducing the sentence to 5 years rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 15,000.
The case pertained to an incident alleged to have occurred on December 27, 2020, involving a 6-year-old victim. The victim's mother had filed an FIR on January 2, 2021, stating that the accused had inserted his finger into the victim's private parts causing bleeding and difficulty in urination. The trial court had convicted the accused under Section 376AB of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) read with Section 4(2) of the POCSO Act, sentencing him to 20 years rigorous imprisonment.
However, upon appeal, the High Court scrutinized the evidence and found discrepancies. While the victim and her mother testified about penetration and bleeding, the medical examination conducted eight days after the incident showed no signs of injury, bleeding, or sexual intercourse. A neighbor who was shown the victim's panties shortly after the incident testified that the panties were clean. The Investigating Officer also confirmed the delay in medical examination and the fact that the clothes had been washed before being seized, weakening the prosecution's case on penetration.
The Court noted the victim's testimony that the accused had placed his hand inside her panty and touched her private parts but found no conclusive evidence of penetration. The delay of seven days in filing the FIR was also found to be suspicious, especially as the victim's mother did not insist on an immediate medical examination despite police advice.
Considering these factors, the Court held that the prosecution failed to prove penetration beyond reasonable doubt, making the conviction under Section 6 POCSO Act unsustainable. However, the act of touching the private parts inside the victim's panty constituted aggravated sexual assault under Section 10 of the POCSO Act, as the victim was below 12 years.
Rejecting the defense plea of false implication on account of unpaid loans and alleged monetary demands as an afterthought, the Court altered the conviction accordingly. The accused was sentenced to 5 years rigorous imprisonment with a fine, and the period already undergone was set off.
This judgment highlights the Court's careful balancing of evidentiary requirements in sensitive child sexual abuse cases, ensuring that the accused is convicted only when the charge is proved beyond reasonable doubt while not absolving the accused of sexual assault when supported by evidence.
Bottom Line:
POCSO Act - Where evidence created reasonable doubt regarding penetration by insertion of finger into private parts of 6 year old victim, conviction for aggravated penetrative sexual assault under Section 6 POCSO Act not sustainable - However, testimony of victim proving that accused put his hand inside victim's panty and touched her private parts made out offence of aggravated sexual assault under Sections 9(m) and 10 POCSO Act - Conviction altered and sentence reduced from 20 years to 5 years.
Statutory provision(s):
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 Sections 3, 4(2), 5(m), 6, 7, 9(m), 10, 42; Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 376AB; Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 Section 216
Bishal Thapa v. State of Assam, (Gauhati)(DB) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3015409