Court emphasizes that extension of time under Order VIII Rule 1 CPC to be granted only in exceptional circumstances beyond defendant's control
In a recent judgment dated 28th October 2026, the Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court, presided over by Justice Sanjay Dhar, dismissed a petition seeking extension of time for filing a written statement in a civil suit. The case involved petitioners Gulshan Kour and another who had failed to file their written statement within the statutory period of 120 days as mandated under Order VIII, Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC).
The respondent, Dali Rani, had filed a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction against the petitioners. After being served summons on 29th August 2019, the defendants filed their written statement on 20th January 2020, well beyond the permissible 120-day period. The defendants subsequently filed an application seeking an extension citing exceptional reasons such as the advanced age and cataract surgery of the defendant No.1, the death of a close relative necessitating travel to Delhi, and an advocate work abstention period.
Justice Dhar, upon reviewing the facts and medical records, observed that the cataract surgery involved a two-day hospital stay only and that the defendant had traveled to Delhi during the relevant period, indicating her capability to communicate with counsel. The court further held that the suspension of advocate work does not constitute an exceptional circumstance warranting extension. Citing the Division Bench ruling in Anoop Dutta v. Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir (2026), the court reiterated that the 120-day period for filing written statements is mandatory and must be strictly adhered to, with extensions granted only sparingly in truly exceptional cases where incapacity beyond control is demonstrated.
The court concluded that the grounds presented were insufficient to justify any indulgence and affirmed the trial court's refusal to extend the time. The petition was dismissed for lack of merit.
This ruling reinforces judicial insistence on procedural discipline in civil litigation and clarifies that general inconveniences or non-medical reasons like advocate strikes do not meet the high threshold required for extension of time under the CPC.
Bottom Line:
Extension of time for filing written statement under Order 8, Rule 1 of CPC can only be granted in exceptionally hard circumstances, where the defendant is incapacitated for reasons beyond their control and subject to the discretion of the court exercised sparingly and cautiously.
Statutory provision(s): Civil Procedure Code, 1908 Order VIII, Rule 1
Gulshan Kour v. Dali Rani, (J&K and Ladakh) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3019131