Court Holds No Offence Made Out Under IPC, IT Act, and Tamil Nadu Harassment Law; Continuation of Trial Deemed Abuse of Process After Prior Contempt Punishment
In a significant judgment dated October 30, 2026, the Madras High Court, presided over by Justice M. Nirmal Kumar, quashed criminal proceedings against advocate R.D. Santhanakrishnan arising from a controversial incident involving inadvertent live streaming of a private act during virtual court proceedings. The case, which had generated considerable public attention, stemmed from a viral video clip showing the petitioner engaged in an obscene act with a woman identified as "X" during a Microsoft Teams virtual hearing in December 2021.
The petitioner faced multiple charges, including Sections 228 (intentional insult to public servant during judicial proceeding), 294(a) (obscene act in public place), 354A (sexual harassment), and 370(2) (human trafficking) of the Indian Penal Code, Section 4 of the Tamil Nadu Prohibition of Harassment of Woman Act, and Section 67A of the Information Technology Act, 2000. However, the Court found that none of the offences were made out on the materials in the final police report.
The incident began when a video clip showing the petitioner's conduct during virtual court hours was circulated on social media, prompting a suo motu contempt proceeding by a Division Bench of this Court and registration of a criminal case by the Cyber Crime Cell, Crime Branch CID, Egmore. The petitioner had pleaded guilty in the contempt case and was sentenced to a brief term of imprisonment, fined, suspended by the Bar Council, and ordered to pay Rs.4,00,000 as compensation to the victim.
Analyzing the criminal charges, the Court observed that the petitioner was unaware that the Microsoft Teams video conference remained running and streaming his private act. His junior colleague admitted to having minimized and muted the video conference, leaving the petitioner oblivious to the broadcast. The Court emphasized that the offences under Section 228 IPC require specific intention to insult or interrupt the court, which was absent here. Similarly, Section 294(a) requires the obscene act to be in a public place causing annoyance to others, whereas the act occurred in the petitioner's private office and was only accidentally visible due to technological circumstances.
Regarding Section 67A of the IT Act concerning publication or transmission of sexually explicit material, the Court noted that the prosecution failed to trace the individual who circulated the video on social media and found no evidence that the petitioner intentionally published or transmitted it. The Court stressed that accidental live streaming without knowledge or volition does not constitute the offence.
On charges of sexual harassment under Section 354A IPC and harassment under Section 4 of the Tamil Nadu Prohibition of Harassment of Woman Act, the Court held that the final report lacked particulars of unwelcome physical contact, explicit sexual overtures, or harassment in public places. The mere general allegations without specific testimony were insufficient. The trafficking charge under Section 370(2) IPC was also dismissed as the prosecution failed to establish the essential elements of recruitment, transportation, or harboring for exploitation.
Importantly, the Court distinguished the criminal proceedings from the earlier contempt case, clarifying that double jeopardy principles did not strictly apply. However, it held that continuing the criminal trial after the petitioner had already undergone punishment and professional consequences for the same occurrence would be oppressive and amount to abuse of the court's process.
The Court, while not condoning the petitioner's conduct, reiterated that the penal provisions invoked must be supported by prima facie evidence, which was lacking here. Exercising its inherent powers under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, the Court quashed the criminal proceedings pending in the Mahila Court, Allikulam, Chennai, thereby bringing relief to the petitioner.
This landmark ruling clarifies the application of criminal laws in the context of virtual court proceedings and the limits of liability for inadvertent technological exposures, emphasizing the necessity of intention and volition in offences involving insult to court, obscenity, sexual harassment, and electronic transmission of explicit material.
Bottom Line:
Quashing under Section 528 BNSS - Where allegations and materials in final report do not disclose essential ingredients of offences under Sections 228, 294(a), 354A, 370(2) IPC, Section 4 of Tamil Nadu Prohibition of Harassment of Woman Act and Section 67A of Information Technology Act, continuation of prosecution amounts to abuse of process - Inadvertent live streaming of private act during virtual court hearing, without knowledge, intention or volition, would not constitute insult to Court, obscene act in public place, publication/transmission of sexually explicit material, sexual harassment or trafficking.
Statutory provision(s):
Section 228 IPC, Section 294(a) IPC, Section 354A IPC, Section 370(2) IPC, Section 4 Tamil Nadu Prohibition of Harassment of Woman Act, Section 67A Information Technology Act 2000, Section 528 Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023
R.D. Santhanakrishnan v. State, (Madras) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3014552