Court Recognizes Matrilineal Societal Norms and Balances Justice with Compassion in Romeo-Juliet Cases Under POCSO Act
In a landmark judgment delivered today, the Meghalaya High Court quashed a First Information Report (FIR) and related proceedings under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012, involving a married couple who were in a consensual adolescent relationship and have two children together. The petitioners, Chandan Thakur and the survivor (petitioner No. 2), moved the Court seeking quashing of the criminal case registered at Sadar Police Station, Shillong, on the grounds that they are legally married and living as husband and wife.
The bench, headed by Chief Justice Mrs. Revati Mohite Dere, highlighted the need to balance the strict enforcement of the POCSO Act with the realities of adolescent consensual relationships, especially in Meghalaya's unique socio-cultural context. The Court referred extensively to its previous ruling in Shri Shalenbor Wahlang v. State of Meghalaya (2026), underscoring the importance of judicial discretion in such "Romeo-Juliet" cases.
The Court noted that the victim had provided informed consent to the relationship, verified through a detailed report by the Secretary of the High Court Legal Services Committee. The report confirmed that the couple had been in a romantic relationship since 2021, married, and have two children aged 4 and 3 years. It also detailed the survivor's educational background, her desire for vocational training as a beautician, and the financial maintenance provided by the petitioner.
Significantly, the Court acknowledged the matrilineal system prevalent in Meghalaya, where lineage and inheritance pass through the mother, giving women greater independence and social security. This societal structure influenced the Court's decision to quash the case, as continuing the trial would serve no purpose and potentially cause injustice to the family unit.
The Court directed the concerned authorities, including the District Child Protection Officer (DCPO) and the District Legal Services Authority (DLSA), to assist the survivor and her children in accessing government welfare schemes and vocational training programs. It also mandated the maintenance of the victim compensation fund, with ₹4 lakhs recommended, half of which has been placed in a fixed deposit for the survivor until she reaches 25 years of age.
The judgment emphasized the necessity of informed consent, the victim's welfare, and the interests of the children born from such relationships. It observed that while the POCSO Act aims to protect society at large, the application of the law must be tempered with fairness, compassion, and an understanding of local customs.
This ruling sets a precedent for the quashing of POCSO FIRs in cases involving consensual adolescent relationships culminating in marriage or cohabitation, provided the victim's consent is genuine and the welfare of all parties is safeguarded.
Bottom Line:
POCSO Act - Quashing of FIR permissible in cases involving consensual adolescent relationships culminating in marriage or living together as husband and wife, subject to judicial discretion ensuring informed consent and welfare of the victim and children born from such relationship.
Statutory provision(s):
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act), Section 528 Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Section 528 BNSS)
Chandan Thakur v. State of Meghalaya, (Meghalaya) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3019140