Appeal Filed Within 45-Day Period Without Certified Copy Deemed Incompetent; Exemption Requests Denied Affirming Strict Adherence to Procedural Norms
In a significant ruling reinforcing procedural compliance under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) Principal Bench at New Delhi dismissed an appeal filed by Anil Khandelwal & NOIDA Holdings Pvt. Ltd. (in consortium) against the Committee of Creditors of Technofab Engineering Limited. The appeal challenged the rejection of a resolution plan by the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), but was dismissed on grounds of non-compliance with mandatory procedural requirements relating to the filing of appeals under the IBC and NCLAT Rules, 2016.
The impugned order was pronounced by the NCLT on July 17, 2026, rejecting the approval of the resolution plan. The appellant filed the appeal on August 29, 2026, which was the 44th day from the order date, hence within the outer limit of 45 days allowed under Section 61(2) of the IBC, including the 15-day condonable delay period. However, the appeal was not accompanied by the certified copy of the impugned order as mandated by Rule 22(2) of the NCLAT Rules, 2016.
The appellant sought condonation of delay in filing the appeal and exemption from filing the certified copy through two interlocutory applications. The appellant argued that the delay was due to a change in counsel and temporary unavailability of the authorized signatory, and contended that the appeal should be decided on merits since the defect was curable and the certified copy was eventually filed.
Opposing these pleas, the respondents highlighted that the application for obtaining the certified copy was only made on the 66th day after the impugned order, well beyond the limitation period. They stressed that the non-filing of the certified copy within the prescribed period rendered the appeal incompetent and non-est, and that discretionary exemptions under Rule 14 could not override the mandatory requirement under Rule 22(2).
The NCLAT bench, led by Mr. Justice Yogesh Khanna, after examining the submissions and relevant Supreme Court precedents, upheld the strict interpretation of limitation and procedural rules under the IBC. The Tribunal emphasized the following key points:
1. The limitation period under Section 61(2) IBC begins from the date of pronouncement of the impugned order. While time taken to procure the certified copy can be excluded under Section 12(2) of the Limitation Act, such exclusion is only available if the party applies for the certified copy within the limitation period.
2. Applying for a certified copy is not a mere technicality but an indicator of the appellant's diligence in pursuing the appeal timely.
3. Filing an appeal without the certified copy and without having applied for it within the limitation period is not a mere defect but renders the appeal incompetent and liable to be dismissed at the threshold.
4. The discretionary power to exempt parties from procedural compliance under Rule 14 cannot nullify the mandatory requirement of Rule 22(2) nor can it be claimed as a matter of right.
The NCLAT referred extensively to Supreme Court judgments including V. Nagarajan v. SKS Ispat, A. Rajendra v. Gonugunta Madhusudhan Rao, Ashdan Properties Pvt. Ltd. v. DSK Global Education, and Angelwoods Apartment Allottees Association v. M. Lalitha which have consistently held that failure to apply for a certified copy within the limitation period is fatal to the maintainability of an appeal under the IBC.
Given that the appellant applied for the certified copy only on the 66th day, well after the limitation and condonation periods expired, and that exemption from filing the certified copy was not warranted, the Tribunal dismissed both the applications for condonation and exemption. Consequently, the appeal itself was treated as non-est and dismissed.
This judgment underscores the strict adherence to procedural timelines and the mandatory requirement of filing a certified copy along with appeals under the IBC. It serves as a cautionary precedent for litigants and their counsel to meticulously comply with filing requirements to preserve their substantive rights.
Bottom Line:
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 - Appeal under Section 61 filed within outer limit of 45 days but without certified copy of impugned order, and certified copy not applied for within limitation period - Such appeal is not merely defective but incompetent and non-est - Exemption under Rule 14 of NCLAT Rules is discretionary and cannot nullify mandatory requirement of Rule 22(2).
Statutory provision(s):
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 Section 61(2), NCLAT Rules, 2016 Rules 14, 22(2), Limitation Act, 1963 Section 12(2)