LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

NCLAT Dismisses Recall Application Seeking Reopening of Delay Condonation Rejection in Insolvency Appeal

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
NCLAT Dismisses Recall Application Seeking Reopening of Delay Condonation Rejection in Insolvency Appeal

Tribunal Upholds Finality of Its Reasoned Order; Rejects Technical Glitch and Subsequent Supreme Court Judgment as Grounds for Recall


In a significant ruling delivered on November 2, 2026, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), Principal Bench at New Delhi, dismissed the recall application filed by Excel Arcade Private Limited, which sought to reopen its rejected application for condonation of delay in filing an insolvency appeal against Unity Small Finance Bank Limited.


The dispute arose after the Adjudicating Authority's order dated December 8, 2025, was challenged by Excel Arcade through Company Appeal (AT)(Ins) No. 330 of 2026. The appellant's delay condonation application was dismissed by the NCLAT on May 22, 2026, on the ground that the appeal was filed beyond the statutory outer limit of 45 days (30 days plus 15 days grace period) prescribed under Section 61(2) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC).


Excel Arcade contended that the delay was caused not by negligence but due to technical glitches in the NCLAT e-filing portal on the last day of limitation, January 22, 2026. The appellant's counsel attempted to e-file the appeal on that day but failed as the portal was unresponsive. An email attaching the appeal was sent to the Registry's IT support as an alternative, which was quarantined by phishing filters. The appeal could only be successfully e-filed on January 28, 2026, thus causing a delay of five days beyond the prescribed limit.


Relying on the recent Supreme Court judgment in Regional Provident Fund Commissioner-II v. Ms. Mamta Binani (2026 INSC 1003), which allowed condonation of delay in a similar technical glitch scenario, Excel Arcade sought recall of the NCLAT's order rejecting their condonation plea. They argued that the date of the first bona fide attempt to file should be considered for limitation purposes under the doctrine of actus curiae neminem gravabit (an act of the court shall prejudice no one).


However, the NCLAT bench, comprising Justice Yogesh Khanna (Officiating Chairperson), Barun Mitra, and Ajai Das Mehrotra (Members Technical), rejected the recall application. The Tribunal emphasized the limited grounds for recall as established in the Supreme Court's Budhia Swain v. Gopinath Deb (1999) 4 SCC 396 decision, which include patent lack of jurisdiction, fraud or collusion, mistake of court prejudicing a party, or non-service of a necessary party. None of these grounds were pleaded or made out by the appellant.


The bench highlighted that the recall application was essentially a disguised review attempt against a reasoned, speaking order which had attained finality because the appellant had not challenged it before the Supreme Court within the prescribed limitation. The Tribunal reiterated that recall powers cannot be used to reopen concluded adjudications or to correct errors of law or fact once an order has become final.


Further, the NCLAT dismissed the appellant's explanation of the five-day delay by citing intervening holidays (Saturday, Sunday, and Republic Day) as frivolous since the e-filing portal functions 24x7x365 and holidays do not impede electronic filing.


The Tribunal also refrained from delving into the merits or examining the NIC report about portal functionality or absence of time stamps, as such issues fall within the ambit of review jurisdiction, which the NCLAT does not possess.


In conclusion, the NCLAT dismissed the recall application with no costs, affirming the principle of finality and res judicata in insolvency proceedings and clarifying that technical glitches alone, without satisfactory explanation for delay beyond the outer limit, do not justify condonation or recall.


This ruling reinforces the stringent adherence to limitation periods under the IBC and clarifies the narrow scope of recall applications in appellate tribunals, thereby ensuring certainty and stability in insolvency adjudications.


Bottom Line:

Recall of a reasoned order dismissing condonation of delay application is not maintainable when grounds recognised for recall are absent; such an application cannot be used as a disguised review after the order has attained finality. Mere reliance on a subsequent Supreme Court judgment and plea of technical glitch in e-filing cannot justify recall, particularly when statutory delay beyond the outer limit remains unexplained.


Statutory provision(s):

Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 Section 61(2), National Company Law Appellate Tribunal Rules, 2016 Rule 11


Excel Arcade Private Limited v. Unity Small Finance Bank Limited, (NCLAT)(Principal Bench, New Delhi) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3014565

Share this article: