In landmark judgment, NCLAT holds Section 55 of Transfer of Property Act applicable to insolvency auctions, directs refund of ₹4.75 crore to bidders, while clarifying "as is where is" does not absolve Liquidator from disclosure duties.
Chennai, November 4, 2026 - The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), Chennai Bench, has delivered a significant judgment in the case of Pankaj Kumar and Another vs. M/s. Praiseworth Infra (P) Ltd. (in Liquidation), addressing the obligations of a liquidator conducting auctions under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC).
The appellants had emerged as successful bidders in an e-auction of immovable properties owned by the corporate debtor, Praiseworth Infra (P) Ltd., ordered for liquidation by the NCLT. The auction was conducted on an "as is where is" and "as is what is" basis, with the liquidator disclaiming any warranties or indemnities regarding the title or condition of the properties.
Following the auction, the appellants deposited earnest money and additional amounts as required. However, after raising concerns about missing title documents and discrepancies in land measurements, the appellants sought the liquidator's assistance to furnish the necessary documentation to ascertain marketable title. The liquidator failed to provide critical "mother" and "great-grandmother" title documents and did not disclose material defects such as encroachments and mismatches between title deeds and actual land extent.
Despite repeated requests, when the appellants were unable to pay the full sale consideration within the stipulated timeline, the liquidator forfeited the entire amount deposited, invoking the auction terms. The appellants challenged this forfeiture before the NCLT, which dismissed their applications. They then appealed to the NCLAT.
In a detailed judgment, the two-member bench comprising Mr. Justice Sharad Kumar Sharma and Mr. Jatindranath Swain, held that the liquidator is not absolved of his statutory duties under Section 55 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, even when conducting auctions under the IBC on an "as is where is" basis. The court emphasized that:
- The liquidator, as the seller's representative, must disclose any material defects in title or property known to him that the buyer could not discover by ordinary care.
- The liquidator must produce all documents of title in his possession or power upon request.
- General disclaimer clauses in tender documents cannot defeat the statutory obligations under Section 55.
- Failure to disclose material discrepancies and withholding critical documents results in information asymmetry, vitiating the fairness of the auction process.
The bench further observed that the liquidator had the means and time to procure the missing documents or, at the very least, disclose their non-availability and its implications in the auction notice but failed to do so.
Regarding the forfeiture of the entire deposited amount, the NCLAT found inconsistency between the newspaper advertisement and the signed undertaking by bidders. While the advertisement broadly stated that the "amount paid" would be forfeited on default, the signed undertaking limited forfeiture to the Earnest Money Deposit (EMD) only. The court held that the signed undertaking, being a binding contract, governs the forfeiture terms and the liquidator could forfeit only the EMD. Therefore, forfeiture of amounts beyond the EMD was illegal.
Consequently, the NCLAT set aside the NCLT orders dismissing the appellants' claims and directed the liquidator to refund ₹4,75,84,375/- (the entire amount forfeited) to the appellants within six weeks. However, the claim for interest at 18% per annum was declined, as the appellants had not exercised due diligence before bidding and had failed to pay the full consideration in time.
The liquidator was also directed to discharge the appellants from any further liabilities arising from non-compliance with the letter of intent, including disqualification from future bidding.
This judgment underscores that "as is where is" conditions in insolvency auctions do not exempt liquidators from disclosing title defects and producing relevant documents. It reinforces the applicability of the Transfer of Property Act's protective provisions even within the IBC framework, thereby ensuring fairness and transparency in liquidation sales.
Bottom Line:
Insolvency and auction sale - Liquidator conducting sale of immovable property on "as is where is" and "as is what is" basis is still bound to disclose material defects in title and property particulars and furnish available relevant information/documents - Section 55 of Transfer of Property Act applies to such auction sale under IBC - Forfeiture of entire amount deposited by successful bidders held illegal; refund directed, but without interest.
Statutory provision(s):
Section 55, Transfer of Property Act, 1882; Section 60(5), Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016; Rule 11, NCLT Rules, 2016; Sections 13, 14 of SARFAESI Act (referenced in case law context)
Pankaj Kumar v. M/s. Praiseworth Infra (P) Ltd., (NCLAT)(Chennai) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3012764