LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

NCLT Mumbai Bench Dismisses CIRP Petition Against Shapoorji Pallonji Over Disputed Operational Debt

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
NCLT Mumbai Bench Dismisses CIRP Petition Against Shapoorji Pallonji Over Disputed Operational Debt

Tribunal rules operational creditor failed to establish undisputed debt exceeding ₹1 crore threshold; invoices barred by limitation and raised in JV's name excluded from claim


The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Mumbai Bench, on 4th November 2026, dismissed a petition filed by Manlift India Pvt. Ltd seeking initiation of the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) against Shapoorji Pallonji and Company Pvt. Ltd. The petition under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) was rejected on grounds that the operational creditor failed to prove the existence of an undisputed operational debt exceeding the statutory threshold of ₹1 crore as mandated by Section 4 of the Code.


Manlift India Pvt. Ltd, a company engaged in leasing and servicing aerial work platforms, had claimed outstanding dues aggregating to approximately ₹5.53 crore for work performed across multiple projects at various locations in India. The operational creditor contended that the corporate debtor delayed payments beyond the stipulated credit period and had defaulted on dues despite repeated demands, including a formal demand notice under Section 8 of the IBC.


However, the corporate debtor, Shapoorji Pallonji, challenged the claim on multiple fronts. Key defenses included that a significant portion of the invoices (41 invoices aggregating nearly ₹89 lakh) were raised in the name of a joint venture (JV) entity, Shapoorji Pallonji & Co. Pvt. Ltd - Shapoorji Pallonji Qatar WLL, which is a distinct legal entity. Consequently, the corporate debtor argued it was not liable for these JV invoices.


Additionally, several invoices were barred by the limitation period. The limitation for initiating proceedings under Section 9 is three years from the date the right to apply accrues, typically the due date of payment. Despite the Supreme Court's directive to exclude the period from 15 March 2020 to 28 February 2022 (due to COVID-19 related relief), invoices dating back to 2018 and 2019 were held time-barred. The operational creditor's argument that a partial payment made after the limitation period extended the limitation was rejected, as acknowledgments must be made before expiry of the limitation period to be valid.


The corporate debtor also raised a plausible dispute regarding nine invoices, citing discrepancies in account reconciliation. The Tribunal noted that reconciliation efforts were ongoing and the existence of genuine disputes precludes initiation of insolvency proceedings under IBC.


Furthermore, the Tribunal held that interest claimed on delayed payments cannot be unilaterally imposed unless contractually agreed. Since the purchase orders did not provide for interest beyond the credit period, the interest component could not be clubbed with the principal to meet the threshold under Section 4. The Tribunal referred to established precedents stating that the principal amount alone must satisfy the minimum debt threshold for triggering CIRP.


The Tribunal also rejected the operational creditor's attempt to club invoices from different projects and work orders to meet the ₹1 crore threshold, holding that consolidation is impermissible unless a common contractual framework exists.


After excluding JV invoices, time-barred invoices, and disputed invoices, the undisputed debt fell below ₹1 crore, rendering the petition non-maintainable. The Tribunal also observed that the corporate debtor had been making payments, albeit delayed, which further supported the existence of a plausible dispute.


The Tribunal thus dismissed the petition under Section 9 of the IBC and disposed of the related interlocutory application filed by the corporate debtor seeking dismissal of the petition as infructuous.


This judgment reinforces that operational creditors must establish a clear, undisputed debt exceeding the statutory threshold and that disputes or limitation bars must be carefully considered before insolvency proceedings can be initiated. It also highlights that IBC proceedings are not meant to serve as substitute recovery mechanisms where genuine disputes exist.


Bottom Line:

Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 - Operational Creditor must establish the existence of an undisputed operational debt that meets the minimum threshold prescribed under Section 4 of the Code for initiating a Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process.


Statutory provision(s):

Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 Sections 4, 8, 9, 10A; Limitation Act, 1963 Article 137


Manlift India Pvt. Ltd v. Shapoorji Pallonji and Company Pvt. Ltd, (NCLT)(Mumbai Bench) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3019166

Share this article: