LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

NCLT Mumbai Bench Dismisses Section 9 Petition as Collusive; Imposes Penalty for Malicious Insolvency Proceedings

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
NCLT Mumbai Bench Dismisses Section 9 Petition as Collusive; Imposes Penalty for Malicious Insolvency Proceedings

Tribunal holds Apkon Ventures and Jas Toll Road Company guilty of abusing insolvency process to evade restitution orders, allows NHAI to intervene pre-admission under Section 65 of IBC


In a significant judgment dated November 5, 2026, the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Mumbai Bench, has dismissed a Section 9 petition filed by Apkon Ventures Private Limited against Jas Toll Road Company Ltd, holding the petition to be collusive and malicious. The Tribunal found that the insolvency proceedings were initiated not for a genuine resolution of insolvency but as a tactical move to frustrate restitution and contempt proceedings pending before the Delhi High Court involving the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI).


The dispute arose from a contractual claim by Apkon Ventures, a service provider engaged by Jas Toll Road Company, a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) incorporated for a highway widening project on NH-4. Apkon Ventures sought recovery of approximately Rs. 1.06 crore along with interest for unpaid retention money under a service contract. Despite issuance of a Work Completion Certificate by Jas Toll Road and repeated demands, payment was not made, prompting the Section 9 petition for initiation of Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP).


However, NHAI intervened under Sections 60(5) and 65 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 ("IBC"), alleging that the petition was filed with fraudulent intent and in collusion with the Corporate Debtor to delay and derail court-ordered restitution of excess toll collections amounting to over Rs. 114 crores. The timeline revealed that the petition was filed immediately after adverse orders from the Delhi High Court directing the Corporate Debtor to deposit the excess toll amount. Further, the Corporate Debtor had failed to disclose the insolvency proceedings to the High Court and had engaged in a settlement with Apkon Ventures, withdrawing the petition only to revive it after defaulting on the settlement payment.


The Tribunal scrutinized the evidence, including the Independent Engineer's rejection of the work executed by Apkon Ventures, an Arbitral Award upholding this rejection, and the Corporate Debtor's silence on the claim during the pendency of the petition. The NCLT also noted the Corporate Debtor's admitted holding of substantial funds invested in perpetual securities, inconsistent with the claim of insolvency over a relatively small operational debt.


Crucially, the Tribunal upheld NHAI's locus to intervene at the pre-admission stage under Section 65, which empowers the Adjudicating Authority to dismiss insolvency proceedings instituted fraudulently or with malicious intent. The judgment relied on authoritative precedents distinguishing the "initiation" of insolvency proceedings (the filing of the petition) from "commencement" (admission by the authority), thereby allowing objections against collusive petitions even before formal admission.


After detailed analysis, the Tribunal held that the Section 9 petition was instituted as part of a collusive arrangement to avoid compliance with judicial directions. Consequently, the petition was dismissed under Section 65 of the IBC. Additionally, the Tribunal imposed a penalty of Rs. 2,50,000 on Apkon Ventures and Jas Toll Road Company, directing payment to the Prime Minister's National Relief Fund.


This ruling sends a strong message against the misuse of insolvency proceedings for collateral purposes and affirms the right of affected third parties to seek early intervention to prevent abuse of the insolvency process. It also clarifies the Tribunal's power to scrutinize the bona fides of Section 9 petitions at the threshold, ensuring that the Code's objectives of timely and genuine insolvency resolution are upheld.


Bottom Line:

Collusive and malicious initiation of insolvency proceedings under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, can be dismissed under Section 65 of the Code if found to be intended for purposes other than genuine insolvency resolution.


Statutory provision(s):

Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 Sections 9, 60(5), 65


Apkon Ventures Private Limited v. JAS Toll Road Company Ltd, (NCLT)(Mumbai Bench) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3019167

Share this article: