LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Patna High Court Dismisses Petition Seeking Direction to RERA Bihar to Lodge FIR on Alleged Fraud

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Patna High Court Dismisses Petition Seeking Direction to RERA Bihar to Lodge FIR on Alleged Fraud

Court Holds that Regulatory Authority Where Fraud is Alleged Must Conduct Inquiry Before Initiating Criminal Proceedings; Petitioner's Writ Petition Deemed Misconceived


In a recent judgment dated November 2, 2026, the Patna High Court, presided over by Justice Sourendra Pandey, dismissed a writ petition filed by Anil Singh seeking a direction to the Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA), Bihar, to lodge a First Information Report (FIR) against certain respondents accused of committing fraud by submitting fabricated documents before RERA.


The petitioner contended that despite repeated requests to RERA, no FIR had been filed against the alleged offenders who, he claimed, had filed false affidavits and concealed material facts in connivance with company directors. The petitioner argued that the fraudulent acts had caused him direct harm, particularly since an adverse order dated October 10, 2025, had been passed by RERA based on the purportedly forged documents.


However, the Court observed that the writ petition was fundamentally misconceived. It emphasized the settled legal principle that the authority or tribunal where the fraud is alleged to have been committed is the proper forum to conduct an inquiry into such allegations. Only after such inquiry, if satisfied that a fraud has indeed occurred, can the authority initiate appropriate proceedings, including lodging an FIR or filing a complaint before a criminal court.


The Court noted that the petitioner had not approached RERA to seek an inquiry or challenge the order on the ground of fraud but had instead directly sought a direction from the Court to lodge an FIR. Furthermore, the petitioner admitted to having filed an appeal against the order dated October 10, 2025, before the Appellate Tribunal but failed to request an inquiry into the fraud allegations before RERA itself.


Justice Pandey held that an Appellate Tribunal is not the appropriate forum to investigate the commission of fraud before the original authority. The power to inquire into such fraud lies with the authority that passed the impugned order - in this case, RERA Bihar. The Court underscored that an FIR or criminal complaint can only be filed post-inquiry and upon satisfaction that forged documents were indeed submitted.


Additionally, the Court referred to a response letter from RERA Bihar dated January 8, 2026, which correctly advised the petitioner to initiate appropriate action on his own as an affected party since the adverse order impacted him. This response was consistent with legal principles and did not warrant interference by the High Court.


Consequently, the Patna High Court dismissed the writ petition, reinforcing the procedural propriety that allegations of fraud before a regulatory body must first be examined by that body before criminal proceedings can be initiated.


Bottom Line:

Fraud committed before a regulatory authority - The authority where fraud is alleged to have been committed is competent to inquire into the matter and take appropriate action, including lodging of an FIR, if satisfied. A writ petition seeking a direction to the authority to lodge an FIR is not maintainable.


Statutory provision(s):

Criminal Procedure Code, Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (implied), Procedural law relating to writ jurisdiction


Anil Singh v. State of Bihar, (Patna) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3019170

Share this article: