LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Patna High Court Upholds Retrospective Application of Supreme Court Ruling on Caste Status in Recruitment Case

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Patna High Court Upholds Retrospective Application of Supreme Court Ruling on Caste Status in Recruitment Case

Candidates of "Tanti-Tantwa" community reclassified as Extremely Backward Class during ongoing recruitment; Court dismisses plea for Scheduled Caste status based on application form


In a significant judgment dated November 5, 2026, the Patna High Court (Division Bench) dismissed the appeal filed by Suman Kumar and others challenging their exclusion from the merit list for the post of Trade Instructor (Fitter) by the Bihar Technical Service Commission. The Court upheld the retrospective application of a Supreme Court ruling which reclassified the "Tanti-Tantwa" community from Scheduled Caste (SC) to Extremely Backward Class (EBC), even though the recruitment process was underway.


The appellants had applied for the post under the SC category, submitting caste certificates and qualifying in the examination stage. However, during the recruitment process, the Government of Bihar issued a Gazette Notification dated August 12, 2024, in compliance with the Supreme Court judgment in Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar Vichar Manch Bihar, Patna v. State of Bihar & Ors. (Civil Appeal No. 18802 of 2017). This notification directed that the "Tanti-Tantwa" community be treated as EBC instead of SC, effectively altering the reservation status of the appellants.


The Bihar Technical Service Commission, acting on this notification, reclassified the appellants under the EBC category and adjusted the merit list accordingly. The appellants did not secure the cut-off marks applicable to the EBC category and were consequently excluded from the final selection list.


The appellants contended that their caste status at the time of application should govern the recruitment process and that changes in caste classification mid-way would render the selection process invalid. They relied on precedents suggesting that recruitment rules cannot be changed after applications are submitted.


Rejecting these contentions, the Division Bench comprising Chief Justice V. Kameswar Rao and Justice Partha Sarthy affirmed the principles laid down by the Supreme Court regarding retrospective effect of judicial decisions. The Court noted that unless explicitly stated otherwise, Supreme Court rulings operate retrospectively and clarify the correct legal position as it always stood.


The Court extensively referred to the Supreme Court's explanation in Directorate of Revenue Intelligence v. Raj Kumar Arora (2025 (3) PLJR (SC) 124), highlighting the Blackstonian theory that courts do not make new laws but discover the correct interpretation of existing law, which applies retrospectively.


The Court also relied on a prior Division Bench decision in Ashutosh Kumar v. State of Bihar (L.P.A. No. 399 of 2022) involving a similar issue of caste reclassification and held that no indefeasible right accrues to candidates based solely on the category claimed in the application if subsequent judicial clarification alters that status.


Ultimately, the Court held that the appellants' exclusion was proper since they failed to meet the EBC cut-off marks. The writ petition and subsequent appeal were dismissed, reinforcing the principle that caste classification for reservation benefits is subject to judicial pronouncements and government notifications, even if issued during an ongoing recruitment process.


This judgment clarifies that the caste status applicable at the time of selection's finalization governs the reservation benefits, not the status declared at the time of application. It also underscores the binding nature of Supreme Court decisions and their retrospective effect unless otherwise specified.


Bottom Line:

Reservation in recruitment - Change in caste status pursuant to Supreme Court judgment - Candidates of "Tanti-Tantwa" community who had applied as Scheduled Caste could be treated as Extremely Backward Class in an ongoing selection process, where the recruitment had not attained finality - In absence of any declaration of prospective overruling, Supreme Court judgment operates retrospectively - No indefeasible right accrues merely on the basis of category mentioned in application form or participation in selection.


Statutory provision(s): Constitution of India, Article 341.


Suman Kumar v. State of Bihar, (Patna)(DB) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3014160

Share this article: