Court affirms Rule 36(4) as valid under CGST Act, dismisses writ petitions challenging ITC reversal notices, emphasizing availability of alternate statutory remedies
In a significant ruling dated October 27, 2026, the Rajasthan High Court (Division Bench) dismissed a batch of writ petitions challenging the constitutional validity of Rule 36(4) of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Rules, 2017. The petitions were filed by M/s. Ravi Infrabuild Projects Pvt. Ltd., Mewar Chamber of Commerce and Industry, and M/s Blue Phosphate Ltd., who sought to quash the rule restricting the availment of Input Tax Credit (ITC) when suppliers fail to upload invoices or debit notes, as well as the consequential show cause notices issued to them under this provision.
The petitioners argued that Rule 36(4), which limits ITC availment to 10% of eligible credit where supplier-uploaded invoices are missing, was ultra vires Section 16 of the CGST Act, 2017. They contended that since they fulfilled all statutory conditions for ITC under Section 16(2), the restriction imposed by Rule 36(4) was not authorized by the parent statute and amounted to an arbitrary penalty on bona fide recipients for suppliers' defaults. Further, they challenged the issuance of show cause notices demanding reversal of ITC amounting to crores of rupees on grounds of invoice mismatches, asserting that such notices should not stand without an effective matching mechanism, which was yet to be implemented.
The Union of India, represented by the Additional Solicitor General and other counsels, defended the rule's validity, contending that Rule 36(4) was introduced as a necessary fiscal and policy measure under the powers granted by Sections 16 and 164 of the CGST Act. They stressed that ITC is a statutory concession subject to conditions and restrictions to prevent fraudulent claims and protect government revenue. The respondents submitted that the rule applies uniformly and fairly to all taxpayers and does not offend constitutional principles. They also highlighted that alternate statutory remedies exist for challenging adverse orders and that writ petitions at the stage of mere show cause notices are premature.
The Court noted that Rule 36(4) was inserted in October 2019 and subsequently amended to tighten the ITC restriction from 20% to 10%. It observed that multiple High Courts, including the Gauhati, Madras, and Kerala High Courts, have upheld the constitutional validity of Rule 36(4). The Court quoted the Gauhati High Court's detailed reasoning, which affirmed that Rule 36(4) derives authority from Sections 16 and 164 of the CGST Act and is consistent with the legislative intent to regulate ITC and curb fraudulent claims.
Further, the Court reiterated the principle that no writ lies against the issuance of show cause notices, referencing the Supreme Court's rulings in Secretary, Ministry of Defence v. Prabhash Chandra Mirdha (2012) and Commr. of Central Excise Commissionerate v. M/ Krishna Was (2019). It held that petitioners must avail statutory remedies such as appeals before appropriate authorities rather than seeking writ relief at the notice stage.
Accordingly, the Rajasthan High Court dismissed the writ petitions, upheld the constitutional validity of Rule 36(4), and declined to interfere with the show cause notices. The Court granted liberty to the petitioners to pursue their grievances through the prescribed statutory channels.
This judgment reinforces the legal framework empowering tax authorities to impose reasonable restrictions on ITC to safeguard the revenue and ensures that taxpayers must comply with procedural safeguards, including supplier invoice uploads, to avail the full credit. It also clarifies that challenges to such rules are to be addressed through appellate mechanisms and not writ jurisdiction at preliminary stages.
Bottom Line:
Rule 36(4) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017, which restricts Input Tax Credit (ITC) availment based on invoices or debit notes not uploaded by suppliers, is constitutionally valid and falls within the scope of Sections 16 and 164 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. Mere issuance of show cause notices under this Rule does not warrant interference through a writ petition, as an alternate statutory remedy is available.
Statutory provision(s):
Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 - Sections 16, 37, 42, 43A (non-enforced), 112, 164; Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017 - Rule 36(4)