Court holds that opening and continuing a history sheet without notice or reasoned satisfaction violates Articles 14, 19 and 21; directs State to frame fairer guidelines for Class-B entries too.
In a significant ruling on police surveillance and personal liberty, the Allahabad High Court has quashed the history sheet opened against Rais Ahmad, a resident of Chandausi and trader at Amroha, and ordered the police to stop all surveillance on him forthwith.
A Division Bench of Justice Siddharth and Justice Vinai Kumar Dwivedi held that opening a history sheet without giving the concerned person an opportunity to object violates the constitutional guarantees of equality, free movement and life and personal liberty under Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution.
The petitioner had challenged Entry No. HS-22A in History Sheet Register No. 8 maintained at Police Station Chandausi, arguing that he had long ago been acquitted in the criminal cases cited against him and had not faced any fresh criminal case for nearly two decades. He also alleged that the police were making repeated domiciliary visits to his home on the basis of the entry, causing harassment to him and his family.
The State defended the action by citing the petitioner’s criminal antecedents and arguing that surveillance was necessary. It also contended that the petitioner had an alternative remedy before the Superintendent of Police.
However, the Court found that no reasoned order showing application of mind had been placed on record to justify the opening of the history sheet. It noted that the petitioner had already been acquitted in the cases relied upon by the police, and that there was no criminal case pending against him when the history sheet was opened.
The Bench examined Chapter XX of the U.P. Police Regulations, especially Regulations 228 to 240, and observed that these pre-Independence provisions reflect a colonial approach toward surveillance and habitual offenders. The Court also referred to a 2022 DGP communication that issued guidelines for opening and reviewing Class-A history sheets, and said similar safeguards were needed for Class-B history sheets as well.
Relying on Supreme Court precedent, including Mangi Lal v. State of M.P. and Swadesi Cotton Mills v. Union of India, the Court reiterated that even where a statute is silent, principles of natural justice must be read into the procedure when rights are affected. It emphasized that a person cannot be subjected to surveillance and police shadowing without notice, objection, and reasoned satisfaction by the competent authority.
The Court further observed that surveillance impacts not only privacy but also freedom of movement and the ability to live without fear of police monitoring. It held that the continued maintenance of the petitioner’s history sheet was unconstitutional and arbitrary.
Accordingly, the High Court quashed the impugned history sheet, allowed the writ petition, and directed that the petitioner’s surveillance be stopped immediately. It also directed the State Government to consider amendments and issue guidelines ensuring that persons proposed to be entered in history sheets are given an opportunity to object before approval, along with annual review of such entries.
Bottom Line:
The opening of a history sheet without adherence to principles of natural justice and constitutional safeguards under Articles 14, 19, and 21 of the Constitution of India violates fundamental rights.
Statutory provision(s): Articles 14, 19, 21 of the Constitution of India, U.P. Police Regulations Chapter XX, Regulations 223-276, Regulation 228, Regulation 229, Regulation 230, Regulation 231, Regulation 232, Regulation 233, Regulation 234, Regulation 240, Section 147 IPC, Section 148 IPC, Section 149 IPC, Section 307 IPC, Section 25 Arms Act, Section 395 IPC, Section 397 IPC, Section 412 IPC, Section 120B IPC, Section 3(1) U.P. Gangsters Act
Rais Ahmad v. State of U.P., (Allahabad)(DB) : Law Finder Doc id # 3162574