Doctrine of merger not applicable after dismissal of Special Leave Petition without leave; question of law remains open for other parties but closed between same parties
In a significant judgment delivered on November 6, 2026, the Allahabad High Court (Division Bench, Lucknow) dismissed a review petition filed by the State of Uttar Pradesh challenging the grant of pensionary benefits to Yamuna Prasad Gupta, a Seasonal Collection Amin. The judgment clarifies the legal position regarding the maintainability of review petitions after the dismissal of Special Leave Petitions (SLP) by the Supreme Court and the applicability of the doctrine of merger.
The case originated from a claim petition filed by the opposite party, Yamuna Prasad Gupta, before the State Public Services Tribunal, Lucknow, seeking the computation of his services from June 5, 1986, the date of his initial appointment, rather than from the date of his regularization on January 16, 2013. The Tribunal had allowed the claim, granting pensionary benefits for the entire service period. Subsequently, the State challenged this decision before the Allahabad High Court, which upheld the Tribunal's order in favor of Gupta, aligning with precedents set for similarly situated employees.
The State further approached the Supreme Court by filing an SLP against the High Court's decision. However, the Supreme Court dismissed the SLP citing no merit, while explicitly keeping the question of law open for future consideration. The State then moved the Allahabad High Court seeking a review of its earlier judgment, relying primarily on the Validation Act, 2021, which bars counting of services not rendered according to rules for pensionary benefits. Notably, this plea was never raised before the Tribunal, writ court, or the Supreme Court.
The Division Bench, comprising Justice Rajesh Singh Chauhan and Justice Shree Prakash Singh, rejected the maintainability objection raised by the opposite party and examined the doctrine of merger in the context of SLP dismissal. Citing the Supreme Court's landmark rulings in Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala (2000) and Khoday Distilleries Limited v. Mahadeshwara Sahakara Sakkare Karkhane Limited (2019), the Court held that dismissal of an SLP without grant of leave does not attract the doctrine of merger. The dismissal signifies the Supreme Court's discretionary refusal to entertain the appeal, and the High Court's judgment remains independently enforceable. Thus, the High Court's review jurisdiction remains intact in such circumstances.
However, the Court clarified that where the Supreme Court dismisses an SLP after considering the merits and finds no merit, keeping the question of law open, such question cannot be reopened between the same parties. The Court emphasized that the question of law remains open only for other parties in future cases but is closed inter se the parties involved in the dismissed SLP.
On the merits, the Court noted that the Validation Act, 2021, was not invoked at any prior stage and could not be introduced for the first time in review proceedings. Furthermore, since similarly situated employees had already been granted pension benefits counting their pre-regularization service, equity demanded the same treatment for Gupta, especially as he had already been extended pensionary benefits.
Consequently, the Allahabad High Court dismissed the review application, reiterating that the benefits granted to Yamuna Prasad Gupta stand affirmed. This judgment not only secures pensionary rights for employees in comparable situations but also offers crucial guidance on procedural aspects regarding review jurisdiction post-SLP dismissal, the doctrine of merger, and the scope of questions of law left open by the Supreme Court.
Bottom Line:
Review after dismissal of SLP - Maintainability - Dismissal of SLP without grant of leave does not attract doctrine of merger and review before High Court remains maintainable - However, where Supreme Court while dismissing SLP on facts finds no merit and keeps question of law open, such question of law is not open inter se same parties, though it may remain open for others in future - New plea based on Validation Act, 2021, not raised before Tribunal, writ court or Supreme Court, cannot be successfully pressed in review.
Statutory provision(s):
Constitution of India Article 136, Code of Civil Procedure 1908 Order 47 Rule 1, Validation Act, 2021
State of U.P. v. Yamuna Prasad Gupta, (All)(DB)(Lucknow) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3014951