LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Andhra Pradesh High Court Dismisses Suit for Specific Performance Over Fabricated Sale Agreement

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Andhra Pradesh High Court Dismisses Suit for Specific Performance Over Fabricated Sale Agreement

Court Highlights Inconsistencies in Evidence, Use of Old Stamp Papers, and Directs Parties to Seek Trial Court Remedy for Alleged Forgery


In a significant ruling on November 10, 2026, the Andhra Pradesh High Court (Division Bench) dismissed the appeal filed by Ramineni Eswara Rao and another, challenging the dismissal of their suit for specific performance of an agreement of sale against Nanapaneni Suresh. The suit pertained to the alleged sale of a 2.74-acre ancestral property in Pedakalakaluru Village, Guntur Mandal, for which the plaintiffs claimed an agreement of sale dated June 8, 2005, and a receipt for part payment dated March 11, 2006.


The High Court bench comprising Justices D. Ramesh and Alapati Giridhar upheld the trial court's findings, which had found glaring inconsistencies in the plaintiffs' case. Central to the dispute was the use of non-judicial stamp papers bearing serial numbers issued in 1997 for the agreement and receipt executed nearly eight years later-a fact that remained unexplained by the plaintiffs and raised suspicion of forgery.


The Court noted that the plaintiffs failed to prove the authenticity of the agreement and the receipt. The evidence regarding the execution of the agreement, the place and circumstances of payments, and the negotiation timeline was contradictory. For instance, the plaintiffs did not obtain an Encumbrance Certificate before paying a substantial advance to a person they barely knew, an unusual and risky practice in property transactions. Moreover, the plaintiffs' witnesses gave conflicting statements regarding the drafting and signing of the agreement and receipt, further undermining their credibility.


The defendant admitted ownership of the property but denied any agreement of sale or receipt of payments. He asserted that in 1997 he had mortgaged the property to one Kanneganti Subbarao, who had taken his signatures on blank stamp papers, promissory notes, and cheques as security. The defendant contended that these blank signed documents were later used to fabricate the sale agreement and receipt in the names of the plaintiffs, who were allegedly strangers colluding with Subbarao to defraud him.


The Court also observed that the serial numbers on the stamp papers used in the mortgage deed of 1997 and the alleged sale agreement of 2005 formed a continuous sequence, a highly improbable coincidence if genuine, which supported the defendant's assertion of fabrication.


Regarding the allegations of forgery and fabrication of documents, the Court referred to provisions under the Indian Penal Code (IPC) Sections 463 (Forgery), 464 (Making a false document), and 467 (Forgery of valuable security) and emphasized the comprehensive legal framework to address such frauds. However, since no sufficient material was placed before the High Court for suo moto action, it directed the parties to approach the trial court under Section 340 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) for a detailed inquiry into the allegations of forgery and fabrication.


The Court dismissed the appeal with costs, reinforcing the trial court's decision that the plaintiffs failed to establish the validity of the agreement of sale or receipt and had not demonstrated their readiness and willingness to perform their contractual obligations.


This judgment underlines the critical importance of credible evidence and proper documentation in property transactions and cautions against reliance on forged or fabricated documents. It also clarifies the procedural recourse available for parties alleging forgery in civil disputes, directing them to seek criminal inquiry through appropriate trial court proceedings.


Bottom Line:

Suit for specific performance of an agreement of sale dismissed due to inconsistencies in evidence, unexplained use of old stamp papers, and lack of proof of transactions and payments.


Statutory provision(s):

Specific Relief Act, 1963 - Sections 10, 20; Indian Penal Code, 1860 - Sections 463, 464, 467; Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 - Section 340


Ramineni Eswara Rao v. Nanapaneni Suresh, (AP)(DB) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3033567

Share this article: