Court holds that incoming developer appointed through court process cannot be saddled with erstwhile developer's refund interest liability; attachment of developer's bank accounts set aside
In a significant judgment delivered on November 5, 2026, the Bombay High Court, in a Division Bench comprising Justices Suman Shyam and Gautam A. Ankhad, set aside an order passed by the Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority (MahaRERA) that had imposed interest liability on a subsequent developer in a redevelopment project. The judgment arose from two writ petitions filed by H. Rishabraj Developers, the new developer of the `Samaj Darshan' redevelopment project in Mumbai, challenging (i) the MahaRERA order dated March 21, 2022, directing the developer to pay interest on Rs. 37 lakhs paid by flat purchasers to the erstwhile developer, and (ii) consequent distraint orders attaching and freezing its bank accounts under the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code.
The facts of the case revealed that the original developer (Respondent No. 5) had taken Rs. 37 lakhs from allottees for a flat in the redevelopment project but failed to refund the amount as per an undertaking given before MahaRERA. After termination of the development agreement due to disputes, the Trust-owner appointed H. Rishabraj Developers as the new developer through a court-supervised process. MahaRERA had earlier registered the project in favor of the new developer, explicitly stating that neither the Trust nor the new developer would be liable for past liabilities of the erstwhile developer.
However, on a review-cum-execution application filed by the allottees, MahaRERA passed an order directing both the erstwhile developer and the new developer to pay interest on the principal amount from the date of the original order till actual realization. Further, revenue authorities attached the new developer's bank accounts to recover the said amount.
The Court carefully analyzed the powers of MahaRERA to review its own orders, the statutory provisions under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA Act), and the facts surrounding the transfer of development rights. The key findings and legal principles laid down by the Court are as follows:
1. Maintainability of Writ Petitions:
The Court held that the writ petitions filed by the new developer are maintainable. The developer had earlier filed and subsequently withdrawn review and appeal proceedings against the impugned order before MahaRERA and the Appellate Tribunal. The Court clarified that withdrawal of such statutory remedies without obtaining liberty to file fresh proceedings is not abandonment of the claim in the writ petitions.
2. Power of MahaRERA to Review Its Orders:
Although Section 53(4)(e) of the RERA Act confers power of review only on the Appellate Tribunal, MahaRERA had framed Regulation 36 under the Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority (General) Regulations, 2017, providing for such review. The Court declined to examine the validity of Regulation 36 in absence of any challenge on that ground, treating it as operative for this case.
3. Non-Impleadment and Liability of Incoming Developer:
The Court emphasized that the incoming developer was not a party to the original complaint, review-cum-execution proceedings, appeal, or remand proceedings before MahaRERA. Mere appearance through an advocate pursuant to a notice did not amount to impleadment. No relief was sought against the new developer in the original or subsequent proceedings. Consequently, MahaRERA could not fasten financial liability on the new developer without impleading it as a party. The order insofar as it imposed liability on the new developer was held unsustainable.
4. Statutory Interpretation of Sections 2(zk), 15 and 18 of RERA Act:
- Section 2(zk) defines a promoter including co-promoters but does not automatically transfer all liabilities of one promoter to another appointed on a `clean slate' basis by court order after termination of the prior development agreement.
- Section 15 prohibits transfer of promoter rights and liabilities without allottee and authority consent and requires "pending obligations" to be complied with by the new promoter. Here, the appointment of new developer was a fresh development agreement with the Trust-owner, not a transfer from the erstwhile developer. The refund liability, already crystallized against the erstwhile developer, was not a "pending obligation" passing to the new developer.
- Section 18 relates to refund obligations where the promoter fails to complete the project. It applies to the promoter who retained the amount. Since the new developer had no connection with the project during the period interest was awarded, Section 18 was inapplicable to it.
5. Attachment and Recovery Proceedings under Maharashtra Land Revenue Code:
The Court quashed the distraint and attachment orders passed under Section 180 of the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code against the new developer's bank accounts. Since the order imposing liability was set aside, consequent recovery actions could not survive.
6. Rights of Flat Purchasers and Liability of Erstwhile Developer:
The Court clarified that this judgment does not absolve the erstwhile developer of its obligations to repay the allottees. The allottees remain free to pursue remedies against the erstwhile developer and/or the Trust in accordance with law.
The judgment underscores the principle that a subsequent developer appointed through a court process on a clean slate basis cannot be burdened with the financial liabilities of the previous developer, especially when not made a party to the original or subsequent proceedings. It also affirms the procedural necessity of impleading parties before liability can be fastened.
This ruling has important implications for redevelopment projects in Maharashtra and other states, providing clarity on the extent of liability of incoming developers under the RERA Act and safeguarding them from unjust financial burdens arising from prior promoters' defaults.
Bottom Line:
Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 - Subsequent developer appointed through court process on a clean-slate basis cannot be saddled with refund interest liability of erstwhile developer towards flat purchasers, particularly when such subsequent developer was not impleaded as party in original complaint, review-cum-execution proceedings or appeal - Recovery and attachment orders against subsequent developer liable to be quashed.
Statutory provision(s): Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 Sections 2(zk), 15, 18, 53; Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority (General) Regulations, 2017 Regulation 36; Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966 Section 180; Constitution of India Articles 226, 227
H. Rishabraj Developers v. State of Maharashtra, (Bombay)(DB) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3013826