Court Rules Minister Lacked Jurisdiction to Convert Devsthan Inam Class III Land into Class I Land or Direct Statutory Authorities; Upholds Absolute Bar on Transfer under 1863 Act
In a significant judgment dated November 2, 2026, the Bombay High Court, presided over by Justice Amit Borkar, declared that the Minister's order converting Devsthan Inam Class III land into Class I land and directing statutory authorities to recognize private ownership and permit transfer was without jurisdiction and legally untenable. The case arose from a petition filed by Samasth Gavkari Mandal, Rithe (AOP), challenging the order passed by the then Minister, Respondent No. 5, who had converted land granted as Devsthan Inam land to Class I Old Tenure, declared certain private individuals as owners, and granted permission for the transfer of such land.
The suit land in question was originally granted in 1862 to Shri Bhairavdev, a deity, as Class III Inam land, a status recorded in official revenue records continuously since before 1929. The villagers, through the Gram Sabha, have traditionally acted as trustees of this land and temple. Respondent Nos. 1(a) to 1(d) applied to the Minister for conversion of the land's status, declaration of ownership, and permission to transfer the land. The Minister, by the impugned order dated August 22, 2014, acceded to these requests and directed the Tahsildar to implement these changes, including removing the deity's name from the revenue records.
The Petitioners contested the Minister's power to pass such orders, arguing the absence of any statutory authority empowering the Minister to convert Devsthan Inam land into Class I land, declare private ownership, or permit transfer, which is expressly barred under Section 8(3) of the Exemptions from Land Revenue (No. 1) Act, 1863. They contended that such powers are vested only in the statutory authorities under the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 (BTAL Act).
The Court examined the statutory framework and relevant precedents, including the Bombay High Court's earlier ruling in Suvarna Appasaheb Kshirsagar and Others v. State of Maharashtra (2025) and the Supreme Court's decision in Chandrika Jha v. State of Bihar (1984). It held:
1. No Ministerial Power for Conversion or Ownership Declaration: The Minister lacked jurisdiction to convert Devsthan Inam Class III land into Class I land. Section 8(3) of the 1863 Act imposes an absolute prohibition on transfer or alienation of such land, which cannot be waived or diluted by the Minister or State Government without formal adjudication by a competent authority. The statutory authority under the BTAL Act alone has the power to declare ownership under Sections 32-G and 70-B.
2. Prohibition Against Ministerial Direction to Statutory Authorities: The Minister could not direct the Tahsildar or other statutory authorities to exercise their discretion in a particular manner. The statutory authorities must independently examine facts and evidence before making decisions under the BTAL Act. The Minister's order attempting to dictate such outcomes was ultra vires and invalid.
3. Invalid Permission for Transfer Under Section 43: The Minister's grant of permission for land transfer bypassed the prescribed statutory procedures and was therefore unlawful.
4. No Authority to Alter Revenue Records: The direction to remove the deity's name from the 7/12 extract and substitute private ownership was also without legal basis.
5. Consequential Directions Without Basis: All consequential directions flowing from the unlawful conversion and declarations were also quashed.
The Court thus set aside clauses 2 to 5 of the impugned order dated August 22, 2014, and disposed of the petition accordingly. The judgment reinforces the principle that executive or ministerial powers cannot usurp or substitute the functions entrusted by law to statutory authorities, especially in matters involving religious endowments and land tenure protected under specific statutes.
This ruling upholds the sanctity of Devsthan Inam lands and the statutory framework designed to protect them from unauthorized conversion and alienation, preserving the rights of traditional trustees and devotees.
Bottom Line:
Minister has no jurisdiction to convert Devsthan Inam Class III land into Class I land or direct statutory authorities under the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 (BTAL Act) to exercise their powers in a particular manner.
Statutory provision(s):
Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948, Sections 32-G, 43, 70-B;
Exemptions from Land Revenue (No. 1) Act, 1863, Section 8(3)