Court Holds Removal from Bank Panel Does Not Constitute Defamation Without Specific Defamatory Imputation and Publication; Plaint Rejected Under Order VII Rule 11(a) CPC
In a significant ruling delivered on October 27, 2026, the Patna High Court, presided over by Justice Ramesh Chand Malviya, dismissed a defamation suit filed by Mantosh Prasad Sinha, a former panel advocate of the State Bank of India (SBI). The suit, seeking damages of Rs. 25,00,000, was filed against senior officers of SBI following Sinha's removal from the bank's panel of advocates for the Jamui Civil Court.
The court's judgment clarified that mere de-panelment or discontinuation of an advocate's engagement by a bank does not amount to defamation under Indian law. The ruling underscored the necessity for a plaint in defamation cases to specifically disclose the defamatory imputation and its publication to a third party, without which no cause of action arises.
Background:
Mantosh Prasad Sinha was empanelled with SBI from 1983 until 2018. The dispute arose when another panel advocate raised doubts about the genuineness of a title deed report submitted by Sinha, leading to his de-panelment by SBI. Sinha alleged that this action damaged his reputation, caused financial loss, and mental agony, forming the basis of his defamation suit.
Earlier, Sinha had initiated criminal proceedings under Section 500 IPC, which were dismissed by the trial court but revived on revision. Parallelly, the civil defamation suit proceeded, with SBI officers denying any defamatory conduct and asserting that the decision to remove Sinha was taken by competent authorities.
Legal Analysis:
The court analyzed the scope of Order VII Rule 11(a) and 11(d) of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC), which allow rejection of a plaint if it does not disclose a cause of action or if the suit is barred by law. It was noted that the trial court erred by not examining whether the plaint itself, on its averments, disclosed a cause of action for defamation.
Referring to precedents including the Supreme Court's decision in Ajay Vijh v. Indian Banks' Association (2026), the court reiterated that the advocate's right to practice law under Sections 29 and 30 of the Advocates Act does not guarantee continued engagement by any client, including a bank. The client's freedom to change or discontinue an advocate is fundamental and lawful.
The court further emphasized the essential ingredients of defamation as per Section 499 IPC: an imputation concerning a person, intention or knowledge to harm reputation, and publication of that imputation to a third person. Mere adverse consequences such as loss of engagement or reputation without a defamatory statement made or published by the defendants do not constitute defamation.
Critically, the plaint failed to specify which defendant made or instructed defamatory publication, when, to whom, and how it was disseminated. General allegations like "spread like anything" or "murmuring everywhere" were deemed insufficient to establish publication. Moreover, the plaintiff's grievance was essentially about the de-panelment itself, not about any defamatory statement, which the court held was a lawful exercise of contractual rights by the bank.
The judgment also noted that claims based on hurt feelings, damaged ego, or financial loss flowing from lawful termination do not amount to defamation under the law.
Conclusion:
The Patna High Court set aside the trial court's order rejecting the defendants' application and instead allowed the petition to reject the plaint under Order VII Rule 11(a) CPC. The suit was dismissed as it did not disclose a legally recognizable cause of action for defamation. No order as to costs was made.
This ruling clarifies that professional disengagement, even if distressing, is not defamation unless accompanied by specific defamatory imputations published to third parties. It reinforces the principle that clients, including banks, have the right to terminate professional relationships without facing defamation liability in the absence of wrongful publication.
Bottom Line:
Defamation - Mere de-panelment/discontinuation of engagement of a bank panel advocate does not by itself amount to defamation - For a civil suit for defamation, plaint must disclose specific defamatory imputation and publication to a third person - General averments of loss of prestige, dignity, reputation and financial loss on account of de-panelment are insufficient - Plaint liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11(a) CPC.
Statutory provision(s): Civil Procedure Code, 1908 Order 7 Rule 11(a), Order 7 Rule 11(d), Section 115; Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 499; Advocates Act, 1961 Sections 29, 30; Indian Contract Act, 1872 Section 203