LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Bombay High Court Upholds Arbitral Tribunal's Procedural Order on Simultaneous Filing of Evidence Affidavits

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Bombay High Court Upholds Arbitral Tribunal's Procedural Order on Simultaneous Filing of Evidence Affidavits

Court Clarifies Limited Scope for Judicial Interference in Arbitration Proceedings, Emphasizing Procedural Fairness and Party Remedies


In a significant judgment dated October 5, 2026, the Aurangabad Bench of the Bombay High Court, presided over by Justice Rohit W. Joshi, dismissed a writ petition filed by Matrix Life Science Pvt. Ltd. challenging an interlocutory procedural order passed by the learned Sole Arbitrator, Justice P. R. Bora, in arbitration proceedings against The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.


The dispute arose out of a compensation claim under a Standard Fire and Perils Policy, where the petitioner had initiated arbitration seeking damages from the respondent insurance company. After framing issues and commencement of evidence, the respondent moved an application before the Arbitral Tribunal seeking a direction for simultaneous filing of affidavits of examination-in-chief of all witnesses proposed to be examined by the petitioner. The petitioner opposed this, arguing that the agreed procedure was to file affidavits witness by witness, and that simultaneous filing would allow the respondent to fill lacunae and alter their strategy unfairly.


The Arbitral Tribunal, relying on the guiding principles of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) and Evidence Act, which the parties had agreed to follow as procedural guidelines, allowed the respondent's application. The Tribunal held that such a procedural order was aimed at ensuring fairness and was not a deviation that prejudiced substantive rights. It also directed that the respondent would follow the same procedure when filing evidence.


The petitioner challenged this procedural order before the High Court, contending that the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to alter the agreed procedure and that the writ petition was maintainable under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.


The respondent raised a preliminary objection to maintainability, citing Supreme Court precedents (notably SBP and Co. v. Patel Engineering Ltd.) that interlocutory orders of arbitral tribunals should not be challenged by writ petitions except in rare and exceptional circumstances involving bad faith, patent perversity, or where a party would be rendered remediless.


Justice Joshi examined the competing contentions and relevant judicial precedents, including recent rulings by the Supreme Court and High Courts. The Court reaffirmed that while Section 5 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 does not bar judicial review altogether, interference in procedural or interlocutory orders should be exercised sparingly and only in exceptional cases. The Court noted that the parties had agreed to follow CPC and Evidence Act principles as guiding procedural norms, and the Tribunal's direction was consistent with Order XVIII Rule 4(1-B) of the CPC, which mandates simultaneous filing of evidence affidavits in commercial suits to ensure procedural fairness.


Further, the Court observed that the petitioner's argument that there was an explicit agreement to file affidavits one witness at a time was not raised before the Tribunal and was a new contention in the writ petition. Even assuming the contention to be correct, the Court held that the procedural order did not cause irreparable prejudice or fall within recognized grounds warranting writ interference. It emphasized that any substantive challenge to such procedural orders could be raised later under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.


Consequently, the Bombay High Court dismissed the writ petition with no order as to costs, underscoring the limited scope for judicial intervention in arbitration procedural matters and highlighting the importance of procedural fairness and the availability of remedies at appropriate stages of the arbitration.


This judgment clarifies the high threshold for judicial interference in interlocutory arbitration orders and reinforces that arbitral tribunals may follow procedural guidelines inspired by civil procedure laws to ensure fairness, provided they do not act in bad faith or cause irreparable prejudice.


Bottom Line:

Arbitration - Interlocutory procedural orders of Arbitral Tribunal can be challenged under Articles 226/227 only in exceptional cases - High Court should be extremely slow in interfering unless there is bad faith, patent perversity, exceptional rarity, or the party is rendered remediless - Direction to file affidavits of examination-in-chief of all witnesses simultaneously is a procedural order and not liable to interference.


Statutory provision(s): Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Sections 5, 19(1), 19(2), 34; Constitution of India Articles 226, 227; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Order XVIII Rule 4


Matrix Life Science Pvt. Ltd. v. The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., (Bombay)(Aurangabad Bench) : Law Finder Doc Id # 2992297

Share this article: