Court affirms limited scope of interference under Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; attributes majority of delay to West Bengal government, upholds damages and interest claims.
In a significant judgment delivered on October 12, 2026, the Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court, comprising Justices Debangsu Basak and Aryak Dutt, dismissed the appeal filed by the State of West Bengal against an arbitral award in favor of Rajpath Contractors and Engineers Limited. The judgment reaffirms the narrow scope of judicial interference under Sections 34 and 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, emphasizing respect for the findings of fact and contractual interpretations made by Arbitral Tribunals.
Background:
The dispute arose from a contract awarded to Rajpath Contractors for the design and construction of a high-level reinforced concrete or prestressed concrete bridge over the River Hogol at Sonakhali on the Calcutta-Basanti Road. The project, governed by Agreement No. 32 of 1996-97, was completed approximately six years later than the scheduled date, with the contractor attributing delays primarily to the State of West Bengal.
The contractor alleged multiple causes for delay attributable to the State, including failure to provide free and unobstructed possession of the site, delayed mobilization advances, obstructions by local groups, and delays in drawing approvals. Conversely, the State contended that the delays were the contractor's fault, citing slow progress and lack of resource mobilization.
Arbitral Proceedings and Award:
A three-member Arbitral Tribunal, consisting of experienced engineers, was constituted to adjudicate the dispute. After extensive hearings and examination of records, the Tribunal found that out of the total 2191 days of delay, 1994 days were attributable to the State, and only 197 days to the contractor. The award, comprising 189 pages, granted the contractor a principal sum exceeding Rs. 3.65 crores, along with interest pendente lite amounting to over Rs. 2.38 crores and costs.
The Tribunal also addressed claims related to loss of profit, escalation, refund of security deposit, and interest for delayed payments. It construed the contractual terms in a manner favorable to the contractor, rejecting the State's arguments on notice requirements and final bill acceptance.
Challenge and Court's Analysis:
The State challenged the award under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, alleging that the claims allowed were contrary to the contract, that the contractor had accepted the final bill thereby waiving further claims, that delays were due to the contractor, and that interest awards were excessive and overlapping.
The Commercial Court at Alipore rejected the challenge, holding that the Tribunal had dealt with all claims and objections with precise and sufficient reasons. The attribution of delay was a factual finding based on a careful review of evidence, and the Court noted it could not reappreciate evidence or substitute its own interpretation.
On appeal, the Division Bench reiterated that the appellate jurisdiction under Section 37 is narrower than under Section 34 and that courts cannot act as courts of appeal over arbitral awards. The Bench emphasized that re-weighing evidence or preferring another interpretation of the contract is impermissible if the Tribunal's view is plausible and reasonable.
Key Legal Principles Affirmed:
- The scope of interference with arbitral awards under Sections 34 and 37 is extremely limited and does not allow courts to reappreciate evidence or substitute their own views on contract interpretation.
- Findings of fact by the Tribunal, particularly on delay attribution, are final if based on evidence and not perverse.
- Claims for loss of profit due to employer-caused delay are recognized heads of damages, even if escalation is paid separately.
- Acceptance of final bills does not ipso facto bar further claims; such questions depend on facts and conduct.
- Interest awarded for delayed payments is within the Tribunal's discretion unless contractually barred, and multiple interest awards do not necessarily amount to duplication.
- Contractual notice requirements and special terms must be construed reasonably; failure to give notice does not automatically bar claims if the employer was on notice and accepted the work.
Conclusion:
The Division Bench affirmed the judgment of the Commercial Court at Alipore, upholding the arbitral award dated September 29, 2014, as corrected by the corrigendum dated October 16, 2014. The Court dismissed the appeal filed by the State of West Bengal, underscoring the importance of finality in arbitration and the limited role of courts in reviewing arbitral awards.
This judgment not only resolves a long-pending dispute concerning a major infrastructure project but also reinforces the principles of arbitration law in India, providing guidance on the judicial approach to arbitral awards, delay claims, contractual interpretation, and interest on delayed payments.
Bottom Line:
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 - Scope of interference under Sections 34 and 37 is extremely limited - Appellate Court under Section 37 cannot re-appreciate evidence or substitute its own interpretation of contract where Arbitral Tribunal has taken a plausible view - Detailed reasoned award attributing delay largely to employer and granting damages, escalation, refund of security deposit and interest upheld.
Statutory provision(s):
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Sections 31(7), 34, 37