LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Bombay High Court Upholds Real Estate Appellate Tribunal's Power to Impose Deposit Condition Exceeding 10 Percentage for Interim Relief in Property Dispute

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Bombay High Court Upholds Real Estate Appellate Tribunal's Power to Impose Deposit Condition Exceeding 10 Percentage for Interim Relief in Property Dispute

Court clarifies that Section 13(1) of RERA restricting promoter's acceptance of advance payments does not limit tribunal's discretionary powers to demand higher deposits as interim condition, balancing equities in high-value real estate litigation.


In a landmark judgment dated November 5, 2026, the Bombay High Court, presided over by Justice Sandeep V. Marne, delivered a detailed ruling in the case of Sachin Bajla v. Honest Shelters Pvt. Ltd., affirming the wide discretionary powers of the Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (REAT) to impose conditions for granting interim relief in real estate disputes.


The appeal arose from an order passed by the REAT on August 8, 2024, which granted conditional status quo in favor of the allottee, Sachin Bajla, in respect of a luxury flat in the Palais Royale project, Mumbai. The condition required Bajla to deposit Rs. 38.18 crores-equivalent to approximately 50% of the agreed sale consideration of Rs. 76.36 crores-to demonstrate bona fide readiness and financial capacity to complete the transaction. Bajla challenged this condition, contending that Section 13(1) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA) restricts a promoter from accepting more than 10% of the sale consideration without a registered agreement for sale, and therefore the tribunal could not impose a deposit exceeding this limit.


The Court meticulously examined the interplay between Section 13(1) of RERA, which caps advance payments a promoter may accept prior to executing a registered sale agreement, and the broad powers conferred upon the REAT under Sections 44(3) and 53 of RERA to pass interim orders "as it thinks fit." It held that the restriction on promoters under Section 13(1) is designed solely to protect homebuyers from financial exploitation by limiting unsecured advances. However, this statutory limitation does not apply to the discretionary, adjudicatory powers of the REAT when granting interim relief.


Justice Marne explained that the tribunal's power to impose deposit conditions exceeding 10% while granting status quo orders is necessary to test the allottee's genuine interest, readiness, and financial capacity to complete the purchase, especially where the project is near completion or possession-ready, and where the promoter faces risk of prolonged litigation and financial loss. This distinction prevents misuse of interim relief by parties who have paid minimal advance amounts yet seek to indefinitely restrain the promoter from selling the property to third parties.


The Court further clarified that the appellant's failure to pay the substantial initial tranche of Rs. 38.18 crores, or to even execute a registered agreement for sale, undermined his claim of readiness and willingness to perform the contract, justifying the REAT's imposition of a hefty deposit condition. It rejected the argument that the tribunal's order indirectly violated Section 13(1), holding that the powers to regulate interim relief and to impose equitable conditions are independent of the promoter's statutory restrictions on advance payments.


Additionally, the Court refrained from delving into the merits of the underlying dispute regarding the termination of the allotment letter or the validity of the complaint before MahaRERA, noting that such issues fall within the purview of the appellate tribunal's final adjudication, not the limited scope of this appeal against an interim order.


The judgment also reinforced the principle that appellate courts should not interfere with discretionary interim orders unless they are shown to be arbitrary, capricious, or perverse. Finding no such infirmity in the REAT's order, the High Court dismissed the appeal.


This ruling clarifies the scope of interim powers of real estate appellate tribunals under RERA, emphasizing their ability to impose financial conditions beyond the statutory advance payment limits applicable to promoters, to balance equities and protect project completion and promoter interests in high-value real estate transactions.


Bottom Line:

Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 - Interim powers of Real Estate Appellate Tribunal - Restriction under Section 13(1) on promoter from accepting more than 10% of sale consideration without registered agreement for sale does not curtail wide discretionary power of REAT to impose deposit conditions while granting interim relief - REAT can direct allottee to deposit amount exceeding 10% for grant of status quo to test bona fides, readiness and financial capacity and to balance equities.


Statutory provision(s):

Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 Sections 13(1), 44(3), 53, 58; Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act, 1963 Section 4


Sachin Bajla v. Honest Shelters Pvt. Ltd., (Bombay) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3013823

Share this article: