LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Delhi court declares AAP councillor's poll victory from Pushp Vihar ward in 2022 void

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |

New Delhi, Nov 20 A Delhi court has declared the election of the AAP's Arun Navariya as the MCD councillor from Pushp Vihar in the December 2022 civic polls void for hiding a past criminal conviction in his nomination affidavit.


The court has declared the runner-up, Naresh of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), elected in his place.


Principal District and Sessions Judge Sanjeev Kumar Aggarwal, in an order dated November 18, noted that the election petition was filed by Naresh under section 15 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation (DMC) Act, which allows a defeated candidate to challenge the results of a poll contest.


Navariya won the December 4, 2022, election by bagging 13,721 votes. Naresh came second with 10,114 votes.


Naresh's plea had alleged that Navariya wrote "Not Applicable" in the column asking for cases in which he was convicted, but the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) leader was convicted in an FIR registered at the Ambedkar Nagar police station under Indian Penal Code (IPC) section 325 (voluntarily causing grievous hurt) in February 2013.


The court noted that Navariya was later released on probation.


Navariya had argued that he had no legal duty to disclose the conviction.


He had relied on Rule 18 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation (Election of Councillors) Rules, 2012, which requires the disclosure of a conviction only if the sentence is imprisonment for a year or more.


Since he was released on probation and never sentenced to jail, he said, nothing needed to be disclosed.


He also cited section 12 of the Probation of Offenders Act, under which a person released on probation does not suffer the disqualification that normally follows a conviction.


In its order, the court noted that candidates must file two affidavits with their nomination, Form 21 and Form 22.


It accepted Navariya's argument on Form 21 but rejected it on Form 22.


Form 21 asks about pending cases with charges framed for offences punishable with two years or more in jail, and about convictions with a prison sentence of a year or more.


On this, the court agreed with Navariya, saying he was not sentenced to imprisonment, much less than for a year or more.


It also noted that Naresh had neither pleaded nor shown that Navariya had breached his probation bond.


"Form 22 is different. Its column 4 asks for 'Cases in which I have been convicted by a court of law (other than those referred to in Form 21'," the court said, adding that it means that a candidate is "required to give details of all cases in which the candidate is convicted and sentenced to imprisonment even for less than one year".


Regarding the validity of Form 22, the court said it was issued by the same authority that framed the rules and called the extra requirement a step "to make the election of municipal councillors more fair and transparent" that "cannot be said to be illegal or beyond their power".


The court said if Navariya was unhappy with Form 22, "he should have challenged the validity of the said Form 22 before an appropriate authority or a court of law but admittedly, he has not challenged the same".


Regarding his release on probation, the court said it may not be a disqualification to contest the election, but according to rules, disclosing past convictions is a must.


"Since affidavit/Form 22 given by the respondent 5 (Navariya) in relation to his criminal antecedents was also displayed on the notice board of the returning officer, which contained the details of his criminal case as 'not applicable', it would give the impression that respondent 5 (Navariya) has no criminal case against him; thus, the same is publication of false information, and thus the same is corrupt practice," the court said.


It said the non-disclosure deprived the voters of their right to make an informed choice.


"In these circumstances, I hereby hold that respondent 5 has adopted a corrupt practice by not mentioning his conviction," the judge said.


He also rejected the argument that a conviction under IPC section 325 does not involve moral turpitude, saying causing grievous injuries "cannot be said to be a non-serious offence" and that "the voters have the right to know that their candidate is convicted in such a serious offence".


The judge noted that section 16 of the DMC Act allows a court, besides declaring an election void, to announce another candidate duly elected.


"Declaring the result of election qua respondent 5 as null and void, the petitioner (Naresh) is entitled to be declared elected ... getting second highest votes," the court said.


It, however, added that Naresh is declared elected "subject to satisfaction by the (Delhi) State Election Commission that petitioner is otherwise eligible for the said post".

Share this article: