Court holds that defendant's continued publication under plaintiff's trademark post-termination of franchise MoU amounts to prima facie infringement and passing off, ordering immediate cessation till next hearing
In a significant ruling on November 5, 2026, the Delhi High Court, presided over by Mr. Justice Tejas Karia, granted an interim injunction in favour of CMYK Printech Limited, restraining Ascendas Media Private Limited from using the trademark and newspaper title "The Pioneer" for its Hyderabad edition. The suit was instituted by CMYK Printech Limited alleging unauthorized use of its long-standing trademark following termination of a franchise agreement with Ascendas Media.
The Plaintiff, CMYK Printech Limited, has been publishing the national English daily newspaper titled "The Pioneer" since 1865. Despite the expiration of earlier trademark registrations and pending renewal/restoration, the Plaintiff demonstrated substantial common law rights and goodwill attached to the mark, which has become a household name in Indian journalism.
Ascendas Media Private Limited had been granted franchise rights through a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) dated June 19, 2018, to publish and circulate the Hyderabad edition of "The Pioneer." Under the MoU, the Defendant agreed to pay a monthly fee and share advertising revenue. However, due to alleged non-payment and defaults, the Plaintiff issued a Termination Notice on February 16, 2026, effective immediately, requiring the Defendant to cease use of the Plaintiff's mark and stop all related publication activities.
Despite the termination and expiry of the six-month notice period stipulated under Clause 19 of the MoU, Ascendas Media continued to print, publish, and circulate the Hyderabad edition under the "The Pioneer" mark. The Plaintiff discovered this unauthorized use in August 2026 and subsequently issued a legal notice through counsel demanding cessation. The Defendant initially assured compliance but was later found to have continued the publication surreptitiously.
The Court examined the evidence including trademark registrations, history of use, details of the MoU, and copies of newspapers published post-termination. It observed that Ascendas Media's right to use the mark was solely dependent on the franchise agreement, which had been lawfully terminated. Continued use of the mark without authorization constituted a prima facie case of trademark infringement and passing off.
The Court further noted the potential for irreparable harm to the Plaintiff's goodwill and reputation, which could not be adequately compensated by monetary damages. Misleading readers and advertisers into believing the Hyderabad edition was still associated with the Plaintiff would cause lasting damage to the Plaintiff's brand.
Accordingly, the Court granted an interim injunction restraining Ascendas Media and its associates from using the "The Pioneer" mark or any deceptively similar mark in relation to newspapers, e-papers, digital media, or related goods and services. The Defendant was also restrained from passing off its publications as those of the Plaintiff.
The suit proceedings will continue, with the next hearing scheduled for March 4, 2027. The Court also exempted the Plaintiff from pre-institution mediation given the urgency of the relief sought, in line with the Supreme Court's ruling in Yamini Manohar v. T.K.D. Krithi (2023).
This judgment underscores the importance of protecting established trademarks and the rights of owners against unauthorized franchisees continuing use post-termination, safeguarding brand reputation in the competitive media industry.
Bottom Line:
Trade mark and passing off - Newspaper title 'The Pioneer' - Defendant's right to use mark flowed only from franchise MoU - After termination of MoU and expiry of six months' period, continued printing and circulation of Hyderabad edition under plaintiff's mark held prima facie unauthorised - Interim injunction granted restraining use of mark in relation to newspapers, e-papers, digital media publications and related goods or services.
Statutory provision(s):
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 Section 12A, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Sections 149, 151, Order II Rule 2, Order XI Rule 1(4), Order 39 Rules 1, 2, 3
CMYK Printech Limited v. Ascendas Media Private Limited, (Delhi) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3033578