LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Karnataka High Court Upholds SIAC Arbitrator Appointment, Rejects Allegations of Institutional Bias in Hotel Management Dispute

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Karnataka High Court Upholds SIAC Arbitrator Appointment, Rejects Allegations of Institutional Bias in Hotel Management Dispute

Appeal by Velankani Information Systems dismissed; Court finds no procedural impropriety or bias in Singapore International Arbitration Centre's appointment of sole arbitrator under Management Agreement


In a significant arbitration-related judgment delivered on November 6, 2026, the Karnataka High Court (Division Bench) dismissed the Commercial Appeal filed by Velankani Information Systems Private Limited challenging the appointment of a sole arbitrator by the Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) and the subsequent arbitral awards in a dispute involving Inter Continental Hotels Group (India) Private Limited and Inter Continental Hotels Group (Asia Pacific) Private Limited.


The dispute arose from a Management Agreement dated November 26, 2009, under which the respondents managed and operated the appellant's hotel. The agreement incorporated an arbitration clause (Clause 18.2) providing for arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and the SIAC Rules, with the sole arbitrator to be appointed by mutual agreement or failing that, by the Chairman of the SIAC. The seat of arbitration was Bengaluru.


The appellant raised objections to the jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal, contending that the SIAC was institutionally biased due to the involvement of the respondents' counsel on SIAC's panel of arbitrators and later as a member of the SIAC Court. The appellant also argued that the SIAC Chairman had declared a conflict of interest and was unable to appoint the arbitrator, and that the President of SIAC lacked authority to make the appointment, rendering the tribunal constitution invalid. Further, the appellant asserted that SIAC's decision to appoint the arbitrator was a review of an earlier decision and thus ultra vires, invoking the doctrine of functus officio.


The Single Judge had earlier rejected these contentions, holding that the SIAC's actions were administrative and did not constitute a judicial review, and that the appointment was made in accordance with the agreed procedure under the Management Agreement and SIAC Rules, 2016. The challenge to the partial award on jurisdiction was dismissed, and the final award was directed to be heard on merits.


In the appeal, the Division Bench affirmed the Single Judge's findings after detailed scrutiny. It emphasized that:


  • The parties had expressly agreed to SIAC as the appointing authority, and the appointment by the Vice President of the SIAC Court was valid under Rules 9.3 and 12.1 of the SIAC Rules.
  • The absence of power to review only applies to judicial or quasi-judicial acts, not administrative decisions such as those involved in appointing arbitrators.
  • Mere association of the respondents' counsel with SIAC as a panel arbitrator or member of the SIAC Court did not establish institutional bias. There was no evidence of any disclosable connection or personal bias involving the arbitrator.
  • The doctrine of functus officio did not apply as SIAC's appointment decision was not a review but a separate administrative act.
  • The appellant failed to demonstrate any ground under Sections 12(3)(a), 12(5), or the Seventh Schedule of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 for disqualification of the arbitrator or SIAC.
  • The partial award on jurisdiction was rightly upheld by the Single Judge, and the appeal was dismissed in entirety.


On the merits, the arbitral tribunal had found the appellant to be in material breach of the Management Agreement by failing to pay fees and wrongfully terminating the contract, and accordingly awarded damages and costs in favor of the respondents.


This judgment reaffirms the principle that arbitral institutions acting under agreed rules are not exercising judicial power when appointing arbitrators and that institutional association alone does not imply bias. It underscores the limited scope of judicial interference under Sections 34 and 37 of the Arbitration Act in challenges to arbitral appointments and awards.


Bottom Line:

Arbitration - SIAC Rules - Challenge to arbitral awards on grounds of institutional bias and improper appointment of arbitrator by the Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) - Rejection of challenge to Partial Award on Jurisdiction upheld - Appellant failed to substantiate allegations of institutional bias or procedural impropriety in the appointment of the arbitrator.


Statutory provision(s):

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 - Sections 12(3), 12(5), 19, 34, 37; SIAC Rules 2016 - Rules 9.2, 9.3, 10.2, 12.1, 28.1, 40.1


Velankani Information Systems Private Limited v. Inter Continental Hotels Group (India) Private Limited, (Karnataka)(DB) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3033577

Share this article: