Tribunal holds clerical errors in IGST reporting under CGST and SGST heads not sufficient to deny ITC if credit pool is intact; but ITC disallowed where supplier failed to pay tax as mandated by Section 16(2)(c) of CGST/UPGST Act.
In a significant ruling dated November 4, 2026, the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (State Bench Lucknow) in the appeal filed by M/s Ram Niwas Sunil Kumar against Deputy Commissioner, SGST, addressed two pivotal issues concerning Input Tax Credit (ITC) under the CGST and Uttar Pradesh GST Acts.
The dispute arose from the Financial Year 2018-19, following a tax demand of ₹6,63,460 (equally split between CGST and SGST), along with a penalty of ₹66,346, imposed on the appellant for alleged excess availment of ITC due to discrepancies between credits declared in GSTR-3B and GSTR-9 returns vis-a-vis Form GSTR-2A.
The appellant contended that an IGST input tax credit of ₹6,71,751.50 was inadvertently reported under CGST and SGST heads owing to a clerical error, without any actual excess availment or tax evasion. It argued that there was sufficient ITC available in the aggregate credit ledger and that the revenue demand was revenue neutral and unjustified. Additionally, the appellant challenged the disallowance of ITC of ₹1,67,790 on purchases from M/s Shree Parasnath Collection, Kamrup, Assam, asserting that these were genuine transactions supported by invoices and banking evidence, with invoices reflected in GSTR-2A.
The Tribunal, comprising Members Narendra Kumar (Judicial) and Alok Chopra (Technical), examined the issues in detail:
1. Incorrect Classification of ITC under CGST and SGST Heads:
The Tribunal noted that mere clerical errors in classifying IGST credit under CGST and SGST do not ipso facto warrant denial of ITC. Relying on judicial precedents including the Kerala High Court's decision in Rejimon Padickapparambil Alex v. Union of India, it highlighted that the electronic credit ledger should be seen as a unified pool encompassing IGST, CGST, and SGST credits. Interest and liability arise only if the total balance falls below the amount of wrongly availed credit. Since the appellant asserted that the aggregate ITC balance was sufficient and the discrepancy was revenue neutral, the Tribunal held that the demand could not be sustained merely on the basis of incorrect classification without verifying actual availability and utilization from original records and the electronic ledger. The matter was remanded to the proper officer for verification and consequential relief.
2. Disallowance of ITC Where Supplier Failed to Pay Tax:
Regarding the ITC of ₹1,67,790 claimed on purchases from M/s Shree Parasnath Collection, the Tribunal emphasized that eligibility for ITC under Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST and UPGST Acts requires that the tax charged must be actually paid to the government by the supplier. The Tribunal observed that although invoices were reflected in GSTR-2A and the supplier filed returns, the returns for the disputed period were NIL, indicating non-payment of tax. Citing authoritative rulings such as Maruti Enterprises v. Union of India and the Supreme Court's decision in Bhandari Scrap Traders v. Union of India, the Tribunal reaffirmed that mere reflection of invoices in GSTR-2A is not conclusive proof of tax payment, and all statutory conditions, including actual tax payment by the supplier, must be cumulatively satisfied. Since the appellant failed to prove this, the ITC claim was rightly disallowed.
The Tribunal, therefore, partly allowed the appeal by directing the proper officer to verify the ITC claims related to the clerical error issue and grant relief accordingly, while dismissing the appeal concerning ITC disallowance due to non-payment of tax by the supplier.
The judgment reinforces the principle that ITC claims must be substantiated by actual fulfillment of statutory conditions and that clerical errors, if bona fide and revenue neutral, should not be penalized without proper investigation. It also highlights the critical importance of supplier compliance in tax payment for the recipient's entitlement to ITC.
Bottom Line:
GST - Mere wrong reporting of eligible IGST input tax credit under CGST and SGST heads due to clerical error does not by itself justify denial of ITC; actual availability and utilisation must be verified from original records and electronic credit ledger. However, ITC cannot be allowed merely because invoices are reflected in GSTR-2A when supplier has not actually paid tax to the Government as required by Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST/UPGST Act.
Statutory provision(s):
Section 16 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017; Section 73 of the Uttar Pradesh Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017; Rule 88B of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017
M/s Ram Niwas Sunil Kumar v. Rakhi Singh, (GSTAT)(State Bench Lucknow) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3012556