LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Bombay High Court Quashes Final Assessment Order for Failure to Serve Draft Assessment Order in Transfer Pricing Case

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Bombay High Court Quashes Final Assessment Order for Failure to Serve Draft Assessment Order in Transfer Pricing Case

Court holds that non-issuance of draft order under Section 144C of Income Tax Act deprives assessee of substantive right to approach Dispute Resolution Panel, rendering final order void


In a significant judgment delivered on October 30, 2026, the Bombay High Court (Division Bench comprising Justices B. P. Colabawalla and Farhan P. Dubash) quashed the final income tax assessment order passed against Orpak Systems India Private Limited for Assessment Year 2022-23. The Court emphasized the mandatory nature of issuing a draft assessment order under Section 144C of the Income Tax Act, 1961 before passing any prejudicial final assessment order in cases involving transfer pricing adjustments.


Facts of the Case:

The petitioner, Orpak Systems India Private Limited, had filed its income tax return declaring a business loss for the relevant assessment year. The case underwent scrutiny as it involved international transactions with associated enterprises, leading to a reference to the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) for determining the arm's length price under Section 92CA(3). The TPO made an upward transfer pricing adjustment of Rs. 2.41 crores, which was incorporated by the Assessing Officer in the final assessment order dated March 24, 2025, under Sections 143(3) and 144B of the Income Tax Act.


The petitioner challenged the final assessment order on the ground that it was passed without first issuing and serving a draft assessment order under Section 144C(1), which is mandatory for "eligible assessees" facing prejudicial variations pursuant to transfer pricing adjustments. The petitioner contended that this failure deprived it of the statutory right to file objections before the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP), a right protected by law.


Contentions and Court's Analysis:

The Revenue admitted, through written instructions, that no draft assessment order had been passed before the final order and termed this a procedural lapse. They sought restoration of the matter to the stage of draft order issuance for the petitioner to avail the remedy before the DRP.


However, the Court rejected the Revenue's contention that the defect was merely procedural and curable. Referring to previous judgments including SHL (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax (2021) and Danfoss Fluid Power Private Limited v. Union of India (2025), the Court held that the non-issuance of draft assessment order in such cases is a jurisdictional error amounting to incurable illegality. It deprives the assessee of a valuable substantive right to challenge the variation before the DRP.


The Court noted that Section 144B(1)(xxi) to (xxix) incorporates the provisions of Section 144C into the faceless assessment framework, making the issuance of a draft order mandatory in cases involving transfer pricing variations. Since the Assessing Officer directly passed the final order without serving the draft, the final assessment order was held to be invalid.


Outcome:

The Court quashed the final assessment order, the demand notice, and the penalty notice issued to the petitioner. It declined to remand the matter to the Assessing Officer but left open the option for the Revenue to initiate fresh proceedings in accordance with law, if entitled.


Significance:

This judgment reiterates the importance of strict adherence to statutory procedures in transfer pricing assessments and upholds the rights of eligible assessees to participate in dispute resolution before final orders are passed. It clarifies that failure to issue a draft assessment order is not a mere procedural irregularity but a fundamental breach of jurisdiction.


Bottom Line:

Income Tax - Eligible assessee - Where variation in assessment arises pursuant to transfer pricing order under Section 92CA(3), passing and service of Draft Assessment Order under Section 144C is mandatory before final assessment - Direct passing of final assessment order under Sections 143(3) and 144B without draft order deprives assessee of substantive right to approach DRP - Such defect is jurisdictional and not a curable procedural lapse - Final assessment order, demand notice and penalty notice liable to be quashed.


Statutory provision(s): Income Tax Act, 1961 Sections 92CA(3), 143(3), 144B, 144C(1), 144C(2), 144C(15)(b)(i), 156, 270A, 274


Orpak Systems India Private Limited v. Assessment Unit (NFAC), (Bombay)(DB) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3012555

Share this article: