Court Rules No Fixed Tenure for Nominated Syndicate Members under University Act, Invokes Doctrine of Pleasure to Allow Government to Revoke Nominations Without Stated Reasons
In a significant judgment dated November 11, 2026, the Kerala High Court, presided over by Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan, dismissed a writ petition filed by Prof. Dr. P.P. Ajayakumar and others challenging the Government of Kerala's withdrawal of their nominations as members of the Syndicate of Sree Narayana Guru Open University. The petitioners contended that the statutory provisions under the Sree Narayana Guru Open University Act, 2021 (Act 2021) guaranteed them a fixed four-year term, which the Government could not unilaterally curtail. However, the Court held that the statute does not confer any explicit right to a fixed tenure for nominated members, allowing the Government to withdraw nominations without assigning reasons, under the implied Doctrine of Pleasure.
The University, established under Act 1 of 2021 to promote innovative online distance learning, constituted its Syndicate under Sections 25 and 26 of the Act. Section 25(1)(ii) provides for eight eminent persons nominated by the Government as Syndicate members, without specifying any fixed term for these nominations. Section 26 mandates that the Syndicate shall be reconstituted every four years and that members' terms shall be co-terminus with the Syndicate's term. The petitioners argued that this implied a statutory right to complete a four-year term.
The Government, however, issued orders withdrawing the petitioners' nominations without stating any reasons, replacing them with new nominees. The petitioners challenged these orders as illegal, arbitrary, and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India, which guarantees equality before the law.
After careful scrutiny of the Act 2021 and a comparative analysis with provisions in other university statutes, the Court found that unlike many other university Acts which explicitly fix terms of office for nominated members, the Sree Narayana Guru Open University Act is silent on the tenure of nominated Syndicate members. The Court observed that Section 26 only fixes an outer limit for reconstitution every four years but does not guarantee a fixed tenure for individual members.
The Court also distinguished between "nomination" and "appointment," noting that nomination, being a designation by the Government without a formal appointment process, carries a different legal footing. Relying on precedents including the Supreme Court's ruling in All Kerala Private College Teachers' Assn. v. Nair Service Society (1994), and the Karnataka High Court's judgment in H. Rajaiah v. State of Karnataka (2000), the Court held that the Doctrine of Pleasure applies where no fixed tenure is prescribed, permitting the Government to withdraw nominations at its pleasure.
Further, the Court emphasized that this power to revoke nominations does not require adherence to principles of natural justice such as prior notice or opportunity to be heard, given the non-stigmatic and non-punitive nature of the withdrawal. The Court rejected the petitioners' contention that the Government's action was arbitrary in the absence of malafide intent or statutory violation, highlighting that the impugned orders did not impugn the petitioners' eminence or integrity.
The judgment also underscored the legislative wisdom in not fixing terms for nominated members in the Act 2021, and that courts cannot substitute their views for the legislature's discretion. The Court urged the petitioners, described as eminent persons, to accept the withdrawal of their nominations gracefully, noting that such acceptance would enhance their dignity rather than diminish it.
In conclusion, the Kerala High Court held that the Government acted within its lawful authority in withdrawing the petitioners' nominations to the Syndicate of Sree Narayana Guru Open University. The writ petition was accordingly dismissed for lack of merit.
This ruling clarifies the scope of the Government's powers in university governance, especially concerning nominated members where the statute is silent on tenure. It reaffirms that in the absence of explicit statutory safeguards, nominated members hold office at the Government's pleasure, balancing administrative control with institutional autonomy.
Bottom Line:
University Syndicate - Nominated members do not have a statutory right to complete their term if the governing statute does not explicitly provide for a fixed tenure. The government has the authority to withdraw nominations, even in the absence of specific reasons, if no statutory violation or malafide action is established.
Statutory provision(s): Sree Narayana Guru Open University Act, 2021 Sections 25 and 26; General Clauses Act, 1897 Sections 16 and 21; Constitution of India Article 14
P.P. Ajayakumar v. State of Kerala, (Kerala) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3033595